PGM Superman #30

[Paratrooper]

As my third free submission when joining the society I will probably send in this one. I got shot down for my GL 76 and My Unknown Worlds #36. But the Superman #30 no matter what grade is probably a shoe-in for slabbing:

 

I'm hoping you agree that it's at least a 4.5

[Aces]

4.5/5.0

 

Check carefully for restro.

 

The black lines around the red "SUPERMAN" letters in the title doesn't look natural and the top front edge looks much sharper than all the others (trim?).

 

This could be just the scan tough.

[Paratrooper]

The black lines in the Superman could be color touch...hard to say, might have to see another copy to be sure. As far as the trimming, it looks like the book was printed off center. But then again, I am just now learning about what restoration looks like. If someone could scan another copy of this book I could compare the two.

[143ksk]

comics.org

[Paratrooper]

thanks 143ksk, but it looks like the book in the link you provided is the one that was trimmed. Still couldn't tell about the possible color touch though.

[flatrock02]

5.0 Wish I had it.

[143ksk]

thanks 143ksk, but it looks like the book in the link you provided is the one that was trimmed.

 

[50 Cent #II (1st)]

4.5

[batman_fan]

4.5/5.0

 

Check carefully for restro.

 

The black lines around the red "SUPERMAN" letters in the title doesn't look natural and the top front edge looks much sharper than all the others (trim?).

 

This could be just the scan tough.

 

[inconceivable]

Pretty close to your guess at 4.5 How bad is the staining? Tear go to the interiors?

 

Dan

[Aces]

Hey!!!!!!!

 

Is that a stamp underneath the SuperMan title!?

 

That's the patent copy!

What a collector's item!

[Paratrooper]

Pretty close to your guess at 4.5 How bad is the staining? Tear go to the interiors?

 

Dan

 

Staining is not that bad and just in the right lower corner. There is a a little tanning at the bottom edge. Not sure how that effects grade. And the tear you see on the cover does not effect any of the interior pages.

[inconceivable]

Pretty close to your guess at 4.5 How bad is the staining? Tear go to the interiors?

 

Dan

 

Staining is not that bad and just in the right lower corner. There is a a little tanning at the bottom edge. Not sure how that effects grade. And the tear you see on the cover does not effect any of the interior pages.

 

Your assessment is pretty good then. Let us know what grade you got.

 

Dan

[Paratrooper]

Will do!

 

I have this Batman #21 I was thinking about submitting at the same time but I have doubts about it's grade. At first appearance it also looks to be a VG but there is a tear on the book that goes through most of the pages, but doesn't effect any of the interior art....I'll post it this weekend to see what you guys think. Gorgeous red cover, would look great preserved.