PGM Flash #119

[esquirecomics]

Using the 2nd OS Grading Guide, I believe conservatively, I assessed this book as a VF-/VF

 

Thoughts? If you disagree, whether upwards or downwards, please be specific.

 

 

 

[Dad&Son-migration]

Gorgeous copy of the front Mark!! Based on just viewing the front scan ( thank you for using a black backdrop on a hard to see yellow color ) I would say you could bump this up slightly to VF/VF+ (8.0-8.5) There appears to be just enough slight color breaking ticks on the spine and the blunted spine corners to keep it off a 9.0

[flatrock02]

Nice looking comic 8.0

[Point Five]

I'd guess 8.0 from the front (soft corners, bit of spine wear, very nice overall). But at this grade level, we'd need to see the back to even have a fighting chance at fine-tuning the grade.

[nik]

Based on the front, looks a tad closer to a VF/VF+

[CJ]

8.0/8.5 from what I see unless there are problems on the back cover

 

 

--Not many colors are better then bright yellow on a comic book

(orange and grey tone are my 2 favorites)

[esquirecomics]

Great! I am too tough on these higher grades. I'll scan in the back when I get home in a few days and get some more thoughts from everyone.

[burntboy]

i think your assessment is pretty much right on. CGC is especially hard on HG SA DC's and despite the fact that i'd tend to call this at least a VF+, they usually were tougher than I was.

 

a spine nick or two, somewhat soft corners and the LLC bindery tear/very slight spine split shouldn't pull this below an 8.0 in almost anybody's book.........

[sterlingcomics]

a tad undergraded....I would say 8.0 would be spot on.

[Aces]

8.0

[marvelcollector]

Based on FC alone 8.5 - 9.0...apparent (slight) foxing along RE near top greatest concern that could knock it down to a VF-....

But, of course..BC needed to better estimate grade....

[Dr_Neff]

7.0 looks good, possible overhang and tear at btm bindery, maybe color flakes or abrasion on spine can't tell 4 sure, off center cover and has this book been cleaned or pressed? assuming it's complete and has a back cover of course with noi defects

[action1kid]

8.0