TEST YOUR GRADING SKILLS

[THE_BEYONDER]

Which one of these books do you think graded the lowest?

 

A

 

B

 

C

 

[Warlord]

Hmmm, how about B?

[THE_BEYONDER]

Hmmm, how about B?

 

What grade would you give it?

[DiceX]

Pretty nice books.

A = 9.6

B = 9.6

C = 9.2 to 9.4

 

So I guess C.

[THE_BEYONDER]

Okay,

So we have one vote for B by Warlord, and DiceX goes for C. Anyone one else want to test thier SKILLS?

 

 

[greggy]

Okay,

So we have one vote for B by Warlord, and DiceX goes for C. Anyone one else want to test thier SKILLS?

 

 

Exceeded your daily limit of views so no dice today!

[THE_BEYONDER]

Okay,

So we have one vote for B by Warlord, and DiceX goes for C. Anyone one else want to test thier SKILLS?

 

 

Exceeded your daily limit of views so no dice today!

 

D'oh!

 

AK,

Let me know your opinion when they come back up tomorrow

 

I'll try to post the back covers as well

[JulianXJ]

A looks very nice with some minor blunting on the lower corners and I count one color-breaking transverse spine crease. Due to that I would give it a 9.2

 

B also very nice with sharper corners and a very nice spine: 9.6

 

C is very slightly mis-aligned with minor blunting and the lower staple looks to be indented a bit. Maybe a 9.0 to 9.2

 

This is just my very limited experience with CGC grading and I have no idea how the actual surface looks or the backs and insides.

 

My vote goes for C as the lower of the three.

 

JulianXJ

[awe4one]

I say C as well...

 

 

Jim

[buttock]

C because the LRH corner.

[ninanina]

C - without a doubt.

[uluru]

Decisions...decisions..A

 

A?

[uclapeterg]

I dont know which grades lower..a spine crease or inverted staple? I will go for A (spine crease)

[GudEnuff2Read-migration]

I would have to say C as lowest also. Unless A is faded and it isn't just the scan, then it's A.

 

A and C filenames are swapped also?

[THE_BEYONDER]

I would have to say C as lowest also. Unless A is faded and it isn't just the scan, then it's A.

 

A and C filenames are swapped also?

 

It isn't just the scan......

[uluru]

A = 9.2

B = 9.8

C = 9.4

 

Is that correct?

[THE_BEYONDER]

A = 9.2

B = 9.8

C = 9.4

 

Is that correct?

 

One of your 3 answers are correct.

[DiceX]

I want another guess, now that I have been CGCafied.

 

A - 9.2

B - 9.0

C - 8.5

[THE_BEYONDER]

I want another guess, now that I have been CGCafied.

 

A - 9.2

B - 9.0

C - 8.5

 

You've got one right as well.....

 

What would you give this book? PPSS # 1

[DiceX]

You've got one right as well.....

 

What would you give this book? PPSS # 1

 

8.0