PGM X-Men #57

[qualitycomix]

Small amount of distributor ink at top left of f/c. Slight rub upper right f/c. Very slight color loss halfway down on spine. Rub bottom left f/c. Small tear on bottom edge f/c near spine. No invisible spine stress or indentations. Clean back cover.

 

[october]

9.0/9.2. Would be an easy 9.4 without the tear. REALLY nice copy!

[mar-vell]

8.5/9.0- lean to higher grade-hard to tell how big tear is

[qualitycomix]

Tear is 1/8 of an inch

[qualitycomix]

9.0/9.2. Would be an easy 9.4 without the tear. REALLY nice copy!

 

Thanks. From the same collection as the #58 I sold you.

[mar-vell]

Tear is 1/8 of an inch

 

9.0

[qualitycomix]

My grade on it is 8.5.

[Dr_Neff]

7.5 nice book though

[action1kid]

9.0

[october]

7.5

 

 

In the new version of the grading guide there is a 9.6 with a larger tear than that. I don't think that would drop it to a VF-.

[Sal]

easy 9.0 imho

[Dad&Son-migration]

9.0

[qualitycomix]

Came back a 9.0 from CGC.

[mar-vell]

Came back a 9.0 from CGC.

 

 

--what was the page quality?

[qualitycomix]

Came back a 9.0 from CGC.

 

 

--what was the page quality?

 

I don't know b/c I didn't write that down when I called in. I know all of this submission was ow or better. I would guess ow or ow/w.