Might possibly resub a book but have a question

[The Troll King]

I have a book that is a 9.6 that I called on today to get the graders notes.

 

The only note was "bend on upper left back cover that does not break color"

 

and that's it!

 

Now, obviously the only reason I would consider resubbing is because I'm looking to sell the book but here's my question:

 

Worthwhile to chance a resub and hope for a 9.8? or even better?

 

I guess I'm not really even sure why that being the only "defect" garnered a 9.6 anyway.

[FFB]

I have a book that is a 9.6 that I called on today to get the graders notes.

 

The only note was "bend on upper left back cover that does not break color"

 

and that's it!

 

Now, obviously the only reason I would consider resubbing is because I'm looking to sell the book but here's my question:

 

Worthwhile to chance a resub and hope for a 9.8? or even better?

 

I guess I'm not really even sure why that being the only "defect" garnered a 9.6 anyway.

 

It's impossible to say without a scan, but from the sound of that defect, you won't get a 9.8 out of it.

[Mr. Zipper]

I thought they didn't have graders notes on 9.4 and above (or was it above 9.4)?

 

Was I incorrect or has this policy changed?

[FFB]

I thought they didn't have graders notes on 9.4 and above (or was it above 9.4)?

 

Was I incorrect or has this policy changed?

 

That's not a concrete policy. Sometimes they do and sometimes they don't.

[Mephisto]

I'd press the bend out if I were you.

[The Troll King]

Well, there is no way that a scan of the graded book is going to show anything because to the naked eye I see nothing!

 

I'm wondering if being in the slab has helped straighten it out any?

[Dr_Neff]

I thought it was they don't keep grader's notes on anything 9.2 or better for modern comics, anybody at CGC care to settle?

[COMICKINGS]

I thought it was they don't keep grader's notes on anything 9.2 or better for modern comics, anybody at CGC care to settle?

I got the same response when I questioned some 9.6's.

[qualitycomix]

Well, there is no way that a scan of the graded book is going to show anything because to the naked eye I see nothing!

 

I'm wondering if being in the slab has helped straighten it out any?

 

You have to find out if it breaks paper. If it doesn't then it can be pressed out.

[ronm3-migration]

Why would there be no notes on the 9.6 or betters? Wouldnt there have to be on everything but a 10 to explain why it isnt a 10?

Especially when there have been so many resubs going from 9.2/9.4's to 9.6/9.8.

[divad]

Why would there be no notes on the 9.6 or betters? Wouldnt there have to be on everything but a 10 to explain why it isnt a 10?

Especially when there have been so many resubs going from 9.2/9.4's to 9.6/9.8.

 

Why? You want to know why? We don't answer questions that start with why.