PGM GA Human Torch #11

[blutobc]

Not trying to overload the forum, but I've got 5 books that I need help grading. I'm listing them separately for ease in reading the responses.

 

1st up - Human Torch #11

stuff you may or may not see...stain on cover, corner wear, edge wear to top cover, tanning to interior edges of cover and some pages.

 

 

[comic_lot]

4.0. Nice book!

[marvelcollector]

3.5-4.0...leaning toward the higher grade despite condition of corners...

[Point Five]

I think safely 4.0. Great one!

[blutobc]

3.5-4.0...leaning toward the higher grade despite condition of corners...

 

This was my thought also. There are enough problems to lower it to 3.5, but then the nice colors, cover smoothness, and the overall tightness has me thinking 4.0 as the final grade.

[Point Five]

Just curious; what's up with the top edge near the right? Any impact to the pages there?

[blutobc]

Just curious; what's up with the top edge near the right? Any impact to the pages there?

 

Are you talking about the corner crease itself? or the indents to the top of the cover?

 

Corner crease does not go into pages.

The top of the cover does show the affect of some chipping(probably started out as a thumb crease. This does affect some of the outer pages as the book appears to have been worn further after the cover chips fell off.

[Point Five]

Fair enough. I could see a case for either 3.5 or 4.0, but great book either way!

[-cryptkeeper-]

3.5

[143ksk]

I could see a case for either 3.5 or 4.0, but great book either way!

 

[rjpb]

3.5/4.0

[burntboy]

i'm thinking as high as a 4.5................