PGM GA Green Lantern #15

[blutobc]

Not trying to overload the forum, but I've got 5 books that I need help grading. I'm listing them separately for ease in reading the responses.

 

2nd up - Green Lantern #15

stuff you may or may not see...tiny chip to bottom of back cover. A really nice book that I'm wondering if others will think of as highly as I do.

 

 

[comic_lot]

6.0. Nice looking book!

[marvelcollector]

5.5...a little to rough overall for a straight FN IMO..

 

(and of course I don't give GA 'bumps"...)

[blutobc]

I'm thinking this one must present better in hand than online.

I was thinking 6.5 with possible 7.0...but of course that is WITH a GA bump.

No chipping to corners...that's just some minor color loss.

 

I'll wait for a few others to chime in to see if I'm bonkers or not.

[143ksk]

6.5

[flatrock02]

5.5/6.0

[Point Five]

I can see why this is a tough one. My guess, and it's just a guess, is that the creasing on the back cover would cap the technical grade at 6.0. The book presents beautifully, and I'd be thrilled even to buy it as a 6.5.

[Mad Dog]

A very nice looking 6.0

[burntboy]

I can see why this is a tough one. My guess, and it's just a guess, is that the creasing on the back cover would cap the technical grade at 6.0. The book presents beautifully, and I'd be thrilled even to buy it as a 6.5.

 

it does present very nicely and perhaps the GA bump might get it up to a 6.0 but i'm thinking i'd agree with the 5.5 - 6.0 guesses due to the chips, stress, dirt and creasing.................