PGM Exciting Comics 51

[Headless Horseman]

It's been awhile and I would like to see how my grading has held up over the years. I might have to sell some books to pay for a purchase where my eyes were bigger than my wallet. I have gotten some stuff off of ebay that sometimes I didn't quite agree with thre grading (thought they were way over graded) and I would like to keep it from happening to someone else. I would really like the person to be happy with what they recieve. I would really appreciate any help on grading.

 

 

[Dad&Son-migration]

a GA 7.5

[Headless Horseman]

Thanks for the reply Dad & Son

[rob_allan]

I'm not going to attempt to grade this until I get my Whiz Comics back and see how my GA grading measures up to CGC.

 

That being said, that front cover is STUNNING. What a great book. Whoever ends up with that is going to be *very* happy. I can picture that in a mylar. It must display really well.

 

Sorry to hear you're having to part with it.

[Headless Horseman]

Rob it does display really nice it's one of my books I really don't cherish the thought of letting go. I just messed up and listened to the little guy sitting on my left shoulder when I should have listened to the little guy on the right

[divad]

Scan appears to be just slightly cropped at the LRFC . . . I'd go a solid 7.0, maybe 7.5 depending on PQ

 

Welcome!

[Headless Horseman]

divad, I should have paid a little more attention when I scanned it I must have shifted the cover a hair when I laid the scanner lid on it I'm thinking that's what makes it look cropped PQ I'd say 8 by the Street card Thanks for the reply it really helps me out alot since I've been out of the circut for a while

[divad]

HH,

Using my better monitor here at work, I pick up a few defects I didn't notice at home (e.g., the 1/8" tear to the REFC). Sorry, but I'm going to downgrade my grade to a 6.5.

 

The dirt on the BC could be lightly cleaned I'm sure.

 

cheers,

d

[Point Five]

Very pretty book. I'll guess a picky 7.0, for the small tears on right edge, light spine wear and some smudges on the back.

 

Welcome to the forums!

[Headless Horseman]

Thanks for the feedback this really helps me alot if I have to part ways with it I really want the person to be happy with it and grade it right! Thanks again you've been a great help!!

[djpinkpanther67]

6.5 - 7.0

[Headless Horseman]

Thanks for the help djpinkpanther

[rjpb]

Very pretty book. I'll guess a picky 7.0, for the small tears on right edge, light spine wear and some smudges on the back.

 

Welcome to the forums!

 

 

on both counts. BC stains might bring it lower technically, but FC looks very nice!

[backtomarvel]

My first reaction was a clear 8.0 and, by golly, I'm sticking with it!

[agro23]

I've had two GA books that clean come back 6.0's. Don't be surprised. BC stains kill grade on white covered books.

 

Otherwise I'd say 7.0 though.

[nochips]

6.5

[143ksk]

6.0-6.5

 

Very cool book