PGM: ASM 4

[Comic Geek-migration]

 

[divad]

Obviously the book has some issues, but it appears to be structurally sound and complete . . .

 

3.5 / 4.0

[topofthetotem]

3.0

[joeypost]

3.5

[marvelcollector]

3.0

[silverweb]

2.5

 

Cover is too damaged to rate a 3.0

 

Major color loss (four spots) and creasing

 

I think that listing this as a 3.5 or 4 would damage your reputation

[rjpb]

2.5

 

Cover is too damaged to rate a 3.0

 

Major color loss (four spots) and creasing

 

I think that listing this as a 3.5 or 4 would damage your reputation

 

 

 

[Dad&Son-migration]

no noticable tears... so I'd go 3.0

[divad]

2.5

 

Cover is too damaged to rate a 3.0

 

Major color loss (four spots) and creasing

 

I think that listing this as a 3.5 or 4 would damage your reputation

 

That's assuming you have one . . . there's no way this book is a 2.5

 

[-cryptkeeper-]

3.0

[rjpb]

2.5

 

Cover is too damaged to rate a 3.0

 

Major color loss (four spots) and creasing

 

I think that listing this as a 3.5 or 4 would damage your reputation

 

That's assuming you have one . . . there's no way this book is a 2.5

 

 

DTA 4.0

[Shadow]

3.0

[Jokerman]

 

 

3.0

 

Joker--

[silverweb]

That's assuming you have one . . . there's no way this book is a 2.5

 

David,

Just because the issue is number 4 does not mean you have to give it a four!

 

[Aces]

2.5

[Point Five]

I can see why this book is tough to grade. A number of positives and flaws.

 

On the plus side, really nice colors & probably gloss as well.

 

But quite a few things on the minus side. The heavy scuffs/tape pulls in the LLC. The crease upper right is quite heavy and distracting...I'd count it somewhat worse than a 'normal' crease. Plus there's a hole right in the center of the cover (y'all catch that?)

 

2.5, possibly a weak 3.0 for the positives but I think 2.5 is safer. Still nice.

[TSwift25]

3.0

[divad]

2.5

 

Cover is too damaged to rate a 3.0

 

Major color loss (four spots) and creasing

 

I think that listing this as a 3.5 or 4 would damage your reputation

 

That's assuming you have one . . . there's no way this book is a 2.5

 

 

DTA 4.0

 

DTA doesn't have 4.0's . . . DTA 6.0

[G.A.tor]

I like 3.0 on this one

[djpinkpanther67]

3.5