PGM Captain Marvel 28

[DaveRhodeIsland]

I know this is in rough shape, but what would you grade it? Thanks!

 

[the blob]

Good+ unless there are chunks or major rips on the back.

[DaveRhodeIsland]

Thanks - no, there are no chunks or rips anywhere. The paper is pretty tan though. Good+ is equal to what numerical grade, roughly? 4-5?

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Thanks - no, there are no chunks or rips anywhere. The paper is pretty tan though. Good+ is equal to what numerical grade, roughly? 4-5?

 

5.0 is high for that book.

[Jeffro.]

Thanks - no, there are no chunks or rips anywhere. The paper is pretty tan though. Good+ is equal to what numerical grade, roughly? 4-5?

 

Good Plus = 2.5

[Rob]

I don't see a need for the "plus". I say Good 2.0.

[rjpb]

I don't see a need for the "plus". I say Good 2.0.

 

At best - maybe only 1.8

[divad]

Dave,

Good to see you posting again, but why would you need a grade for this book???

-d

[DaveRhodeIsland]

Dave,

Good to see you posting again, but why would you need a grade for this book???

-d

 

Just to see what a really ratty book in my collection grades at. I have no intention of trying to do anything with it. Just satisfying my overly curious mind I guess.

[Dick Pontoon]

I sez .5 or 1.0 on second thought

[mdandy8]

Has to be 1.5 or so...

 

Moment of silence for this poor book, started life off rough, dropped and stepped on at the LCS before getting to the spinner rack where he was crushed down many times watching his brothers and sisters fly off the rack. Later to be sent to the .25 box where he was picked up by a 12 year old who read it 20 times, stuffed him under the bed and later traded him to his best friend for a pack of gum.

[Shark]

I think all of the creases in the world gathered together on this one comic book.

 

I'd say Fair (1.0) to Fair/Good (1.5).