FWIW, I voted for Ditko and that was it.
As for Romita, I didn't like Spider-man run, but not because he was a bad draftsman.
He's a perfectly competent artist and told a story well, but (and it's a big but) his PP constantly whined about his life while simultaneously being smarter than almost everyone in the world, more handsome that all but a handful of people, dating three of the best looking women to ever grace a comic (Gwen, MJ, and Felicia) and saving lives left and right.
Basically, JR drew the strip so beautifully that I suffered from cognitive dissonance between PP's whining and the life JR showed.
Just didn't and don't enjoy it.