• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Black_Adam

Member
  • Posts

    3,150
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Black_Adam

  1. Buyers who use GPA to gauge value also need to remember that not all CGC graded comics are created equal. Comics in the same grade (ie 9.4) can have different PQ, miswraps, writing on cover, etc. So a perfectly centered white-paged clean copy can easily command more than many recent GPA sales.

    And sometimes a seller just knows a comic is worth more than recent sales show. About 3 years ago a beautiful CGC 9.2 FF 49 was listed for sale at about 25% above GPA. Before I could even think about lowballing the seller another boardie jumped on it. The comic has tripled in value since then. Made the same mistake on a mid grade FF #5. doh!

     

  2. 1 hour ago, lizards2 said:

    I think I'll take it as a curiosity piece at this point, so that maybe I can learn more about restoration.  The staple placement looks weird, if that was actually monkeyed with, and I want to examine the trimming.

    :takeit: 

    Normally with this issue I look for copies like the one shown below, with the cover aligned to show the sole of Thor's boot (often cut off) touching the bottom of the page, which should leave approximately 1/4" of red above the letterhead. On this "file copy" issue half of the toe of Thor's boot is missing and there is minimal red above the letterhead - I would guess this comic has been heavily trimmed top and bottom. Still a decent deal at the price paid though and one I was tempted to pull the trigger on myself despite the obvious (and duly noted) hatchet job.

    Journey Into Mystery #114 in 4.5

  3. 2 hours ago, namisgr said:

    Glad you were able to win one of the books for your collection.  That Thor is an especially good win, because it's an unattributed Suscha News pedigree copy.  It's also got history on the Boards - I bought it from Batmiesta, who had it reholdered and let me know it had come from the premier picture frame Marvel collection of them all.

    So if I ever get it reholdered I can just give CGC your number and they will add the pedigree? :wishluck: