The Superman #172 and Aquaman #46 books above should be a QUALIFIED 9.2 and 9.4, respectively.
The key visual being that the defects on the label are described in ALL CAPS, which is only for Qualified defects.
I have seen other books where the label color was wrong but the census had it correct. From the Superman 172, though, the label is blue and the census lookup shows that in fact it was graded as universal.
So then it is a mistake on the label and the census? Surely no book could grade a 9.2 with a cover detached at one staple, right?