why do so many people get confused, (or in past cases extremely butt hurt) in this thread, whenever an actual discussion occurs.
It is not the "books for cheerleading thread"
If the thread is called, "books that are heating up", then people should discuss whether or not a book is heating up or not.
When so many people post books which are clearly NOT heating up, but which they either want to heat up, or others have told them are going to heat up, they should not be surprised, or shocked, or offended, that people might actually question saying:
"are you sure thats heating up?"
"here are some sales that seem to point otherwise".
Ultimately, its either a dont ask dont tell thread, where people only cheerlead for books to go up up and away, or its a discussion thread about what is heating up, and that involves both sides of the discussion, for the books that are mentioned.
Lastly, i wasnt scrutinizing the book, though legitimately curious WHY it was brought up in this thread (where it clearly does not belong).
If you don't want to respond to my posts, don't.
Please don't edit my posts down to the point of using them as a launchpad for your next monologue.
Thanks in advance.
Chopping someone's post up like that and then using to make some "insightful" observation is just plain lame .
As a clarification on internet rules: if someone makes multiple points in a post, how does someone responding know which points they're allowed to respond to?