I mean, I'm not a variant chaser-- especially an error variant chaser, but I've sold both, and have gotten about a 5% premium for the black label. There's no doubt it's the "true" first printing, and that others in some cases are willing to pay a little more for it. If I could turn back time, I would have kept my 9.8 black label for good.
Which actually reminds me, I've owned six copies, not five!
No offense, thats COMPLETE speculation and a 5% bump is completely useless in terms of determining which is more sought after.
Way to many factors (time of auction (if it was even an auction?), month, day, year, viewers, scans, avenue sold, what else was avail at the time, etc) to consider a 5% bump material.
I'm just going off what I know, man. And like i said, whenever one was for sale, the first question is always "is it a black label?!"