silveragecollectibles618 -- 11,000+ positives, 0 integrity. I'd buy a short box full of Stan Lee forgeries from tonfulle-84 before I'd do business with this guy again.
In short, he bought an Uncanny 120 from me for $18 shipped, description of which, in part, contained the following:
"NOTABLE FLAWS: The main flaw of this book is that it has become slightly wavy, I believe due to moisture exposure (touch gives that impression, and there also appears to be a water stain on the back cover which should be visible in the photo)." [I also graded the book at a 3.0 overall]
A couple days after shipping I get a "not as described" return request (demand; you can't not accept these, because eBay). Reasoning? "This book is water damaged. Did not say so in the description."
I somewhat tersely reminded Mr. buyer of the lengthy sentence I wrote on the topic, response was "well, its coming back regardless". Ultimately I was going to lose any debate with eBay, because eBay. So finally I said spoon it here's your money back, send the book back or don't, I don't give an excrement. Figured why pay return shipping and/or additional blood money to eBay for a book that I just wanted a little beer money for?
I also wasted a bit of time filling out two of those "Report Buyer" reports, in the second one I made sure to mention that I know eBay doesn't give an excrement about what transpired and I doubt anyone reads these anyway.
I'll follow-up and award homeboy one integrity point if the book actually does show back up in my mailbox.