I'm unsure of the issue here. Is it because the date is incorrect for the signature? I consistently have the wrong dates on items Ive gotten graded....especially sketched books. Does anyone know that AC didn't talk to McFarlane about holding the book since they are one of his facilitators? Sometimes you make judgement calls for customer service. This guy doesn't seem like a reseller and probably didn't know about Todd's CGC rules. He doesn't advertise them at cons and many people don't tie themselves to CGC forums. Sometimes you bend a rule to take care of your (CGC, McFarlane, and AC) customer. Similar to when retailers do returns on items even when the items are past the return date. Certain situations have circumstances tied to them that validates a bend of the rule. I think going on a witch hunt, crucifying a facilitator and pretending to be CGC without knowing what actually took place from all sides is a little harsh. As stated by someone before, this is done more than most probably want to admit.