boron

@Superman2006  Thanks once again for the ongoing analysis !

Congrats to the winners !

5 points - now if we could just do some Olympic scoring and throw out the best round and worst round.

On 4/27/2024 at 9:54 AM, ADAMANTIUM said:

I was fine until eyeing that Superman book, I thought perhaps NM as well for it, or I just didn't do due diligence, like at all

12 pts

I saw some major fugly flaws on the right side of that front cover - gave it a 6.0

25 days past April 1st -    still being fooled - 

Grades in

Bull streak ended at 6, with a large  undergrade on Frankenstein (had it at 8.0).

Showcase and Supes I had at 9.2.  Bull on Spidey.  6 points this round.  

I appreciate the effort - thanks for the stats !

I have a similar question, but not regarding the credits.  The question is regarding the discounts for the paid level - do they cross services ? - i.e If I am a Premium Comic member with a 20% grading discount, would I get 20% off card grading also ? 

Please put me in, coach !

On 2/12/2024 at 1:37 PM, TheGeneral said:

Congrats to the finalists! I feel like this is the closest grouping we've had to end a contest. Nail-biting finish!

Congrats on your consistent great results !

On 2/10/2024 at 9:22 PM, JohnH19 said:

Congrats on your perfect round!

Thanks -  must be a Winnipeg thing !  

Grades in.  Thanks Mike for another contest !  And thanks to the folks that do the analytics!

On average, I am right on the mark 

Round 2 - undergraded  11pts

Round 3 - overgraded - 11pts

I can only conclude at this point that my 4th place finish last contest was a fluke.

Grades submitted - have relaxed my 'get off my cover' grumpiness. 

11 Points -  I am much too harsh an undergrader.  Time to send in some books.

5 points,

2 bulls, undergrade by 1 on the last two.

but had IM at 8.0

Please sign me up, thanks!

On 11/6/2023 at 10:40 PM, TheGeneral said:

Whew, tricky triple 5's! Had my grade ranges as 5.0-5.5, 4.5-5.0, and 5.0-5.5 on the three books. As part of my final decision I thought there was a higher chance that each grade would be different, so I made sure to mix it up lol. 

Found my notes which I thought I had discarded.  Initially  6, 5, 5.  Then 6,5,4.5 -  Then I speculated that it might be 6,5,4 just because.   6,5,5 still would have lost as the TheGeneral had the first tie-breaker.

Congrats to @TheGeneral !    Looking forward to the next contest !      

Grades in ! Fingers crossed !  Eyes uncrossed.

Thanks  @Superman2006 for your analysis (and  for annointing me as most-improved) !

Once again thanks, Mike, for running and administering the contest.