I was awaiting the outcome of the current Heritage auction to make my choice, and that's why I give the nod to Bat 1. I'm a Timely fan. My last pickup was a Cap 3. I badly wanted Cap 1 to win this fight, but it just didn't. Not in the Heritage duel between the two. Although I agree that Cap 1's cover wins by a nautical mile, I can't agree about the book content. I put them at even. Long term, I think the Batman movies have shown resiliency thru a parade of actors. It even survived Michael Keaton. Batman movies will keep coming, and new Batman fans will be generated with each new movie. The resiliency of Captain America movies is untested. Chris Evans is great, and I hope he never leaves. But he will at some point, and then the question is whether or not the next guy will meet acceptance. I'd like to think yes, because then just like Batman, we will continue to grow new enthusiasts.
p.s. I just put up the emoji to Filter81's Bat 1 this morning