My mistake was throwing a bid on an auction without really looking at the book. Not a big deal, not a key, not a lot of money.. just want to know if my hypothesis is correct.
The item, an Incredible Hulk #112 was a couple of minutes from closing. I saw CGC 9.0, I saw what seemed to be an undervalued high bid, bing bang boom I placed my bid and a couple of minutes later the book was mine.
Then I looked a little more closely (on the small screen/phone). Yeeeeesh lol. How could this possibly be a 9. The heavy foxing, and it appears the bottom staple may be rusted.
My theory is the book was amateurely pressed and overhumidified in the process, and straight to CGC. Being an old slab, it's had its years for that moisture to take effect. My subtheory is that transparent whites on the cover/back are a dead giveaway for a press.
Im I correct in these assumptions? I'll also assume if the slab was cracked and regraded, it would get a ~ 7.5
Thanks!