• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

XxSpideyxX

Member
  • Posts

    259
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by XxSpideyxX

  1. What was your primary reason for purchasing this book? 

    If you’re intention is to sell at some point in the future, will you advertise this as a 9.8 book or a 9.2 that happened to score higher for whatever reason?

    If your purchase was solely to own the best version of the book possible, obviously that didn’t happen.

    So I don’t see a winning outcome here for anyone unless you are able to return it.  If you can’t, you have a few less favorable options:

    1). Sell the ‘9.8’ and kick the can down the road to the next buyer (please don’t).

    2). Sell as a 9.8 that ‘presents’ like a 9.2 (honest, but not sure I’ve ever seen this).

    3). Crack it and sell raw with plenty of pictures and hope to recoup your money (Caveat emptor).

    4). Learn to live with it but stare at the those ticks every time you look at the book.

    5). Give it to me to relieve the stress (win/win scenario).

  2. What was your primary reason for purchasing this book? 

    If your intention is to sell at some point in the future, will you advertise this as a 9.8 book or a 9.2 that happened to score higher for whatever reason?

    If your purchase was solely to own the best version of the book possible, obviously that didn’t happen.

    So I don’t see a winning outcome here for anyone unless you are able to return it.  If you can’t, you have a few less favorable options:

    1). Sell the ‘9.8’ and kick the can down the road to the next buyer (please don’t).

    2). Sell as a 9.8 that ‘presents’ like a 9.2 (honest, but not sure I’ve ever seen this).

    3). Crack it and sell raw with plenty of pictures and hope to recoup your money (Caveat emptor).

    4). Learn to live with it but stare at the those ticks every time you look at the book.

    5). Give it to me to relieve the stress (win/win scenario).

  3. 11 hours ago, MGsimba77 said:

    Not sure what you mean by not perfectly square? I think you're referring to the very slight over-wrap where the M in Marvel is very close to the spine? Most of them look that way. It looks great imo.

    Just speculating but I think the grades not easily available like perhaps 9.2 and up will fetch higher provided its well centered. The census is not low but you just don't see 9.2s listed everyday.

    I've seen silver age OW pagers go just as high or higher as white in high grades. Maybe people don't mind PQ as much in silver age if the eye appeal is good enough and it's an important issue? I know for me personally Its not important if the eye appeal is right. Bronze may be different. 

    Btw, there was a 39 9.0 in Pedigree's recent auction went for ~1700 if memory serves. I don't remember the PQ but it was the highest sale ever by a mile. That's obviously an outlier but the trend on these high grade silvers is clearly up!

    Hey Simba!  Yeah, I agree the book looks great.  I just meant that for the extremely high amount that this book went for, I would have thought (on face value) that the book would have been all white or otherwise presented almost flawlessly for the grade.  I've typically seen 39 go for 10%-15% more than 40.  Either way, it's a great sign for these books :)   

  4. On 12/8/2019 at 7:17 PM, MGsimba77 said:

    You referring to the #40 9.2 that went for 1600? I think that may be the highest ever. 

    Anyone looking for a high grade 39 or 40 should be ready to put up top dollar. PQ doesn't seem to be a factor on top grades 

    Wonder why that 40 went so high?  It wasn’t even all white pages or perfectly square.  I got a 9.0 39 earlier this year for far less.  Very odd.