Game: BRONZE AGE SURVIVOR SERIES- Round 6

[Mr. Zipper]

It's a classic cover by arguably the best artist of the era.

 

Which amounts to about two dead flies in the "BA importance" category.

 

But feel free to nominate it in the "Classic BA Cover" contest, just as I will ASM 136.

 

Where is it stated that the contest is about "BA Importance?" If it's modeled after "Survivor" I can pick any reason I want to vote off as book. I'd rather keep a classic cover around longer than some of the first appearances of irrelevant, B-list characters, IMO.

 

BTW, if the first Survivor thread was strictly about "SA Importance," X-Men #1 would have been voted off much sooner than it was!

[whetteon]

Swamp Thnig #1 needs to go, no need for 1st app. and 1st app. in own book.

 

True-r words have never been spoken. (thumbs u

[joe_collector]

Where is it stated that the contest is about "BA Importance?" If it's modeled after "Survivor" I can pick any reason I want to vote off as book.

 

And so can I, which I JUST DID!

[MK Ultra]

I voted for Iron Fist 14. Sabretooth had no importance at all in the Bronze age whereas it seems that all other titles had more importance in the bronze age.

[tth2]

WWBN 32.

[Scheradon]

Jimmy Olsen 135 'bout time!

 

Superman #233 (new direction)...now why the heck is this one still here? Time to go "new direction".

[Monstro]

sticking to my guns and going with Detective Comics 395

[Monstro]

What's with the hate for Supes 233? The "new direction" element is irrelevant. It's a classic cover by arguably the best artist of the era.

 

agreed

[sterlingcomics]

Most of the Marvels on this list is irrevelant...nice to see the Marvel Zombies jump on the DCs.

 

First Bullseye...First carpy appearance of a carpy character.

[Mr. Zipper]

Now that JC is suspended for two weeks, I presume this contest is dead... unless JC had a successor plan.

[chrisco37]

I should be voting for IF #14 as I trash that book any chance I get. Instead, I'll vote for Bats #234 as I have the past few rounds; 1st BA Two-Face, how is that important in the least?

 

When have "we" ever given any significance the "first BA appearance of" anyone? And, it doesn't even have the classic cover factor.

[chrisco37]

Now that JC is suspended for two weeks, I presume this contest is dead... unless JC had a successor plan.

 

Where were he and tim fighting? Was it here, and postes have been deleted?

[Zonker]

Yes and yes.

 

(oops, actually it was the Round 5 thread, not this one)

[Mr. Zipper]

Now that JC is suspended for two weeks, I presume this contest is dead... unless JC had a successor plan.

 

Where were he and tim fighting? Was it here, and postes have been deleted?

 

In the round 5 thread.

 

JC made threat. Tim took him up on it. JC suddenly found a reason to back out. Threats of Brazilian Death Match, etc. Then JC dropped a racist comment with profanity... probably because he knew that would result in all connected posts getting deleted.

[alwaysbronze]

[whetteon]

Banned just before Swamp Thing #1 is about to take a dirt nap. It's a DC conspiracy I tell you!

[Raphael]

who's going to continue the survivor thread now?

[alwaysbronze]

who's going to continue the survivor thread now?

 

Shadow

[blutobc]

who's going to continue the survivor thread now?

 

Shadow

 

(thumbs u

Hopefully. No reason for the thread to stop. JC can pick it back up in two weeks with only 4 books gone.

[seank]

Defenders