PGM Hawkman #1

[comicdonna]

Actually, It's my daughter's. It's going to CGC in a week or so, and was wondering what you guys think it will get for a grade.

 

 

[gernblanston]

Hard to tell from the faraway scan, but possibly 5.5/6.0?

[topofthetotem]

5.5

[TFL-migration]

5.5

[JohnT]

4.5. The spine has pretty large stress creases every quarter inch or so. But decent eye appeal on the rest of the book.

 

Why seal this classic away in plastic?

[blue808]

4.5/5.0

[burntboy]

i'll stick with my first reaction and go with a 5.5...............

 

while there's not much wrong with this book other than the spine, there are far too many spine nicks on both the front and back covers to garner a 6.0, IMHO.

 

one of my favorite characters of the 60's...........and those 6 B&B covers by Kubert were to die for...........

[Calamerica]

VG/F 5.0

[abracadabra]

It's hard to tell from the pic, but I think a 5.5. But with some of the SA grades I have been seeing lately, you may even get a "bump" and get a soft 6.0...

[comicdonna]

4.5. The spine has pretty large stress creases every quarter inch or so. But decent eye appeal on the rest of the book.

 

Why seal this classic away in plastic?

My daughter likes slabs.

 

I appreciate everyones opinions. I'll give it a solid 5.0

[Shadow]

5.5

[bhhooks22]

6.0.......BH......