Who belongs in the SA Artists Survivor Series list?

[TheWatcher]

I've compiled a preliminary list of artists for the SA Survivor Series. Would like input on artists whose names I've left off. I tried to cover all genres, but I'm sure I forgot a few. Also, thoughts on those artists that straddle the line between SA & BA.

 

Angelo

 

 

Jack Kirby

Steve Ditko

Russ Heath

John Severin

John Romita Sr

Gil Kane

Carmine Infantino

Curt Swan

Jim Steranko

Don Heck

Joe Kubert

Joe Maneely

Jerry Grandenetti

Mike Sekowsky

Wally Wood

Bill Everett

Frank Frazetta

Reed Crandall

Alex Toth

Gene Colan

Jim Aparo

Murphy Anderson

Neal Adams

John Buscema

Bernie Wrightson

Nick Cardy

George Tuska

Robert Crumb

S. Clay Wilson

 

[font:Arial Black]Latest Additions[/font]

 

Gilbert Shelton

Dan DeCarlo

Harry Lucey

Carl Barks

Joe Sinnott

Marie Severin

Warren Kremer

Giordano

Ross Andru

Mort Drucker

Fred Ray

Barry Windsor-Smith

Matt Fox

Ogden Whitney

Russ Manning

Ayers

[Mac Man]

I saw all of the ones I'll be voting for!

[piper]

pretty good list!

[Red Hook]

Joe Sinnott was a penciler as well as an inker.

[shiverbones]

looks good to me. Kirby vs. Adams ala Frazetta vs. Eisner is my guess.

[chrisco37]

You can add Marie Severin to the list.

[TheWatcher]

Joe Sinnott was a penciler as well as an inker.

 

Thanks, Brad. Forgot about him.

[143ksk]

Gilbert Shelton

Dan DeCarlo

Harry Lucey

Carl Barks

 

[TheWatcher]

You can add Marie Severin to the list.

 

Yeah, I thought about about adding her name but passed. Kinda like I did with Herb Trimpe & Sal Buscema. Nothing against them, but I didn't want the list to get too long. I asked this question in the GA Survivor thread: Do Adams & Buscema belong on the SA list?

[TheWatcher]

Gilbert Shelton

Dan DeCarlo

Harry Lucey

Carl Barks

 

 

Thanks, Steve (thumbs u

[chrisco37]

Gilbert Shelton

Dan DeCarlo

Harry Lucey

Carl Barks

 

 

Thanks, Steve (thumbs u

 

WTF! You leave Marie off the list b/c you don't want it too long, but now you're going to add 4 more?

 

Expect a visit from Voodoo Joe.

[TheWatcher]

Gilbert Shelton

Dan DeCarlo

Harry Lucey

Carl Barks

 

 

Thanks, Steve (thumbs u

 

WTF! You leave Marie off the list b/c you don't want it too long, but now you're going to add 4 more?

 

Expect a visit from Voodoo Joe.

 

 

Just for you, Chris

[chrisco37]

I was kidding, of course. Your original list was good for me.

[DrWatson]

I was kidding, of course. Your original list was good for me.

You are going to have to toughen up. That baby will be here before long.

 

BTW... Good list, Angelo.

[TheWatcher]

I was contemplating her anyway

[selegue]

Fine starting list! All the most obvious names are there.

Victor Moscoso?

Groundbreaking, but could he last more than one round?

Joe Sinnott?

Where would SA Fantastic Four be without him?

Marie Severin?

Important at SA Marvel. Her humor work was unique and impressive.

Ramona Fradon?

I think that her style on e.g. Aquaman and Metamorpho was influential.

 

Are Aparo and Wrightson really Silver Age? I think of them more as harbingers of the Bronze Age, but maybe I don't know their Silver Age work well enough. I am prepared to be educated.

 

Jack

 

[PS -- Some of these suggestions were already added. My message was a long time between starting and sending!]

 

I've compiled a preliminary list of artists for the SA Survivor Series. Would like input on artists whose names I've left off. I tried to cover all genres, but I'm sure I forgot a few. Also, thoughts on those artists that straddle the line between SA & BA.

 

Angelo

 

 

Jack Kirby

Steve Ditko

Russ Heath

John Severin

John Romita Sr

Gil Kane

Carmine Infantino

Curt Swan

Jim Steranko

Don Heck

Joe Kubert

Joe Maneely

Jerry Grandenetti

Mike Sekowsky

Wally Wood

Bill Everett

Frank Frazetta

Reed Crandall

Alex Toth

Gene Colan

Jim Aparo

Murphy Anderson

Neal Adams

John Buscema

Bernie Wrightson

Nick Cardy

George Tuska

Robert Crumb

S. Clay Wilson

[innocuous]

Jack Kirby? I thought I saw him in the GA poll. He lasted a few rounds, so you may as well take him off this list.

[Dick Pontoon]

Them's fightin' words, mistah!

[500Club]

You can add Marie Severin to the list.

 

Yeah, I thought about about adding her name but passed. Kinda like I did with Herb Trimpe & Sal Buscema. Nothing against them, but I didn't want the list to get too long. I asked this question in the GA Survivor thread: Do Adams & Buscema belong on the SA list?

 

Adams best body of work was bronze, but he did have a late silver age presence.

[Scrooge]

Could we consider (and probably reject) the following:

 

Warren Kremer

John Stanley

Pete Morisi

Giordano

Ross Andru

Mort Drucker

Fred Ray (heck, why not if Maneely is listed in the SA when he died in 1958!!)

Russ Heath (please don't forget to include him or Troop's going to come down on your @$$!)

 

More as they pop up.