PGM Action Comics #89

[comicdonna]

 

[Point Five]

Front presents well; chips & stains on the back. (Does front have staining? Can't tell from photo....)

 

4.5ish...

[BlowUpTheMoon]

The front does present very well. But that BC liquid stain brings it down to a 4.5 - 5.0.

[gernblanston]

5.0

[Comicdey]

That's a great book, I'm not going to go as high as these other guys on the grades due to the heavy tanning and back cover water staining and minor chips. 4.0......leaning to a 4.5.

[thedude]

4.0 ish

[comicdonna]

My guess is about a 4.5 Certainly the lowest grade of the 4 books I posted.

[djpinkpanther67]

VG+

[Calamerica]

VG 3.5 - 4.0 tops.

[Monstro]

5.0

[mr.schomburg]

depending on page quality 5.0, if brittle at all then 2.5

[Aces]

4.5

 

Wierd cover...

 

 

[comicdonna]

I just got the grade of this book online.

 

Universal 4.0 Lt tan/off-white pages

 

Not a big suprise. The good news it that my Action run has a minimum of 4.0 to fit in the collection. A 3.5 would not be good.

[EastCoastExchange-migratio]

4.0

[backtomarvel]

Holy *^$#!!!! Talk about a cover ahead of its time ... by like 30 years before the late '60s! Love it.

 

5.0 easily, maybe 5.5 in hand, mainly because of the slack golden age books have earned. Looking for strict present-day grading and it's a 4.0 for sure and likely a 4.5 in hand.

[JohnT]

I just got the grade of this book online.

 

Universal 4.0 Lt tan/off-white pages

 

Not a big suprise. The good news it that my Action run has a minimum of 4.0 to fit in the collection. A 3.5 would not be good.

 

What does Lt tan/off-white mean? What about cream? Does it mean the page quality varies that much throughout the book?

 

Cool book! I was going to say 5.0...which may not bode well for the upcoming grading contest.

[trmoore54]

I'll go with 4.5...

[comicdonna]

I just got the grade of this book online.

 

Universal 4.0 Lt tan/off-white pages

 

Not a big suprise. The good news it that my Action run has a minimum of 4.0 to fit in the collection. A 3.5 would not be good.

 

What does Lt tan/off-white mean? What about cream? Does it mean the page quality varies that much throughout the book?

 

Cool book! I was going to say 5.0...which may not bode well for the upcoming grading contest.

That's a good question. Maybe someone will chime in with the anwser.

[innocuous]

Resub for a 4.5

[thedude]

4.0 ish

 

looks like I nailed this puppy !