SA ARTIST SURVIVOR SERIES: RD.7

[TheWatcher]

Well, it seems we had another tie. Our fondest farewell to Ayers, Frank Frazetta & Marie Severin (sorry, Arex). Since it worked so well in the past, same thing this time around

 

 

[Blind Owl]

Picked Andru & Toth not in any order per se!!!

 

Sorry Andru & Toth fans!!!

[1koko]

This is already getting difficult.

 

Andru and......Infantino

[JohnT]

It's definitely getting tougher. I went with Colan and Buscema. Buscema is one of my favorite artists...of the Bronze Age.

[thirdgreenham]

I went with Cardy and Crandall.

 

Andy

[brasseye]

Boy that is tough!

I think realisticly a cut down list of 4 would be more like it. This list above is a who's who of the some the greatest comic book artists ever to grace the medium.

[selegue]

Boy that is tough!

I think realisticly a cut down list of 4 would be more like it. This list above is a who's who of the some the greatest comic book artists ever to grace the medium.

 

No kidding! It's really down to favorite/not favorite now. Great list!

 

Colan wasn't too tough to vote down, but I wavered between Kubert and Crandall for the other. Opposites -- Kubert was very evident on DC covers during the Silver Age, but I don't care for his style as much as the other artists. Reed Crandall is top five for me in ability and style, but was a less obvious contributor during the Silver Age, working mostly for Dell/Gold Key, Treasure Chest, Warren magazines, Tower, etc. -- titles I rarely read. In the end I went with Kubert *CHOKE* but will be back for Crandall next round. (More likely Crandall will be gone and I'll vote Kubert and lord-knows-who next round.)

 

Jack

 

 

[tth2]

Still easy for me. Andru because I never cared for his style and Crandall because I really view him as a GA artist.

[Sal]

Andru and Colan. The two weakest left, imho, although i think Andru is terribly underrated. Crandall and Swan are next.

 

 

cannot believe Anderson has votes. but there you go

[shiverbones]

yup, getting tough! Andru & Infantino for me.

[toro]

It's already getting tough, so I guess I'll go with Crandell and Andru.

[-cryptkeeper-]

Ross Andru

Carmine Infantino

[Karma23]

Andru and Swan

[fanfourforever]

Who are the individual_without_enough_empathys who keep voting for Neal Adams?

[Dick Pontoon]

I haven't voted for him yet, but it's coming, for no other reason than I don't care for his style.

[The Troll King]

Kirdy and Ditko

 

Yes, I'm one of the ones that keeps voting for both of them because I just don't think their stuff is that great especially in the silver age.

[TheWatcher]

Kirdy and Ditko

 

Yes, I'm one of the ones that keeps voting for both of them because I just don't think their stuff is that great especially in the silver age.

 

So, you like their BA work better?

[cd4ever]

Crandall and Heath. Mostly because I don't know who they are.

[burntboy]

Who are the individual_without_enough_empathys who keep voting for Neal Adams?

 

i suppose these are some folks who don't include Neal among their "favorite" Silver Age Artists....................

 

it's hard to argue over someone else's personal tastes............

[cd4ever]

Who are the individual_without_enough_empathys who keep voting for Neal Adams?

 

i suppose these are some folks who don't include Neal among their "favorite" Silver Age Artists....................

 

it's hard to argue over someone else's personal tastes............

 

I would argue he didn't do enough SA work to last much longer.

Far and away, his best stuff was in the BA.