SA ARTIST SURVIVOR SERIES: RD.12

[TheWatcher]

John Buscema

 

You've done a great job after taking over the thread Watcher.

 

 

Thanks, bro (thumbs u

not to derail, but who started this shindig?

 

The concept: Cap_FF; SA edition: moi

[Doctor Svord]

Now, Wally Wood, didnt do a lot for me :shrug:

 

Get thee back Sandwich! (Man I miss Spy Magazine.)

 

 

 

[DrWatson]

John Buscema

 

You've done a great job after taking over the thread Watcher.

 

 

Thanks, bro (thumbs u

not to derail, but who started this shindig?

What is your definition of started. Angelo has been involved with Silver Age from the get go.

then where did the "after taking over" come from?

Cap did one or two rounds of GA artists and then Ang took over.

[Doctor Svord]

Wally Wood and the attack of the freaky eight legged ant.

 

 

 

[blutobc]

Heath this round for me and possibly Wood for the next round even though I like his Thunder Agents stuff it's not enough to knock the other guys out.

[Blind Owl]

Has to be Wood this time. Again great artist, but I don't consider him as much in the silver age!!!

[mar-vell]

sorry russ but i am not familiar with your work!

[Aman619]

Buscema. Wood is far more top=rate, but he can t go that far in a SA poll anyway, so looks like a sad farewell to a good run for ol Wally. But after him, we gotta start hacking away the also rans left.

[selegue]

sorry russ but i am not familiar with your work!

 

Sure you are!

 

 

 

Jack

 

 

[toro]

Has to be Wood this time. Again great artist, but I don't consider him as much in the silver age!!!

 

Totally agree! Great is an understatement, but for Silver Age he has to go!

[JohnT]

Romita for me. Too bland to be one of the greats.

[djpinkpanther67]

Wood was instrumental in the GA, DD #1 was the only notable SA book he did (IMO)...judging from the polls so far, it seems a lot of others are in agreement

[tth2]

Buscema (not good enough) and Wood (not SA enough).

[tth2]

I just realized we were supposed to just vote for 1, but I think I was able to submit 2 votes.

[joe_collector]

Russ Heath.

 

Never trust anyone with two first names.

[joe_collector]

I just realized we were supposed to just vote for 1, but I think I was able to submit 2 votes.

 

Someone confirm this, and if so, then let's re-vote.

[shiverbones]

Jack, I never realized those ads were by Heath! Thanks!

[selegue]

Wood was instrumental in the GA, DD #1 was the only notable SA book he did (IMO)...judging from the polls so far, it seems a lot of others are in agreement

 

Well, this is the "Who drew your favorite Silver Age Marvel superhero?" poll, right? Daredevil must be someone's favorite!

 

More seriously, I am now surprised that Colan got the boot before Heath and Kubert. Kubert because people are mixing him up with one of his X-Men-drawing sons? Heath because people are afraid that Paratrooper will kick their patoots if they vote him down?

 

I had to vote down Wood. One key Silver Age Marvel superhero book just isn't competitive.

 

[PS: Duh! I should have written "a short run on a second-tier Silver Age Marvel superhero". Of course I realize that Wood introduced the red suit with heavy black "Wood shading", not the red, yellow and black circus suit. Don't get me wrong -- I really like Wood (check current avatar).]

 

Jack

[Blind Owl]

Jack, I never realized those ads were by Heath! Thanks!

 

I didn't either!!! WOW!!!!

[selegue]

I just realized we were supposed to just vote for 1, but I think I was able to submit 2 votes.

 

Someone confirm this, and if so, then let's re-vote.

 

I just tried it and it only accepted one vote.

 

Jack