CONTEST - GUESS THE CGC GRADE - 3 Awesome Goldenage Books

[divad]

[pastandpresentcomics]

3.0

5.0

7.0

[Count]

3.0

6.0

6.5

[piper]

4.5, 7.0, 8.0

[inconceivable]

Superman #24 5.5 FN-

Tomb of Terror #3 7.5 VF-

Wonder Woman #57 8.5 VF+

 

Dan

[Paris_Fred]

3.5

4.5

6.5

[Drummy]

4.0

8.0

7.5

 

Dan

[AlexH]

5.0, 7.5, 8.0

 

The front cover (top) of the Superman book looks trimmed. But it is tough to tell from a scan.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Called and no grades today.

 

 

How about today?

[Buck Biggins]

Waiting on response if graded.

[CAMERANIAC]

3.5

6.0

7.0

 

Hey, those are my guesses!

3.5

6.0

7.0

[CAP Freak]

Who won?

[Buck Biggins]

Sorry still not graded. As soon as I hear I will let everyone know. Should be done any day.

[Buck Biggins]

BOOKS HAVE JUST BEEN GRADED.

 

Below is everyone's estimates......

 

………….. ………. Sups24 \ Tomb3 \ WW57

The_Spirit ………. 4.5 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

Point Five ………. 4.5 \ 7.0 \ 7.5

hesdeadjim ………. 3.5 \ 6.5 \ 6.0

joeypost ………. 4.0 \ 6.5 \ 6.0

BloUpTheMoon ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 7.5

Varfleet ………. 4.5 \ 6.5 \ 7.5

djpinkpanther67 ………. 3.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

The_Beyonder ………. 4.0 \ 6.0 \ 7.0

rob_allan ………. 3.5 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

divad ………. 4.0 \ 7.5 \ 7.5

MCMiles ………. 4.0 \ 7.0 \ 7.0

qualitycomix ………. 3.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

october ………. 4.5 \ 8.0 \ 8.0

agro23 ………. 3.5 \ 6.5 \ 7.5

nik ………. 4.0 \ 7.5 \ 7.0

trmoore54 ………. 4.5 \ 7.0 \ 7.0

topofthetotem ………. 3.5 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

comicdey ………. 5.0 \ 7.5 \ 7.5

Warlord ………. 5.0 \ 8.0 \ 8.0

comicdonna ………. 4.0 \ 6.0 \ 7.0

Buck Biggins ………. 5.0 \ 8.5 \ 8.0

silverage12c ………. 4.0 \ 7.0 \ 7.5

Sal ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

tatterdemalion ………. 4.0 \ 8.5 \ 7.0

catrick339 ………. 4.5 \ 7.0 \ 8.5

hellblazer ………. 5.0 \ 8.0 \ 8.5

CAP_Ffreek ………. 3.5 \ 7.0 \ 6.0

thedude ………. 5.0 \ 6.5 \ 8.0

Theagenes ………. 3.5 \ 7.0 \ 6.5

mrwoogieman ………. 3.5 \ 6.0 \ 7.0

143ksk ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

Aces ………. 4.0 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

scheradon ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 7.0

LordRahl ………. 4.0 \ 8.5 \ 7.5

Kenkoy ………. 4.0 \ 5.0 \ 6.5

Osborn_fr ……….4.0\7.5\8.0

Toro…………4.5\7.0\7.5

Mac Man………..4.5\6.5\7.0

Burntboy……….4.5\7.5\8.0

Hepcat…………3.5\7.5\8.5

pastand presentcomics………..3.0\5.0\7.0

Count…….3.0\6.0\6.5

Piper……..4.5\7.0\8.0

Inconceivable……..5.5\7.5\8.5

Paris-Fred……..3.5\4.5\6.5

Drummy………….4.0\8.0\7.5

AlexH……..5.0\7.5\8.0

 

[Buck Biggins]

[font:System][font:System]Tomb of Terror 3 8/52 Universal 8.0 OFF-WHITE 8.0 [/font]

 

Superman 24 9-10/43 Universal 5.5 OFF-WHITE 5.5

 

Wonder Woman 57 1-2/53 Universal 8.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE 8.0 [/font]

[Buck Biggins]

I bolded the people who guessed correctly. Looks like no one won.

 

………….. ………. Sups24 \ Tomb3 \ WW57

The_Spirit ………. 4.5 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

Point Five ………. 4.5 \ 7.0 \ 7.5

hesdeadjim ………. 3.5 \ 6.5 \ 6.0

joeypost ………. 4.0 \ 6.5 \ 6.0

BloUpTheMoon ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 7.5

Varfleet ………. 4.5 \ 6.5 \ 7.5

djpinkpanther67 ………. 3.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

The_Beyonder ………. 4.0 \ 6.0 \ 7.0

rob_allan ………. 3.5 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

divad ………. 4.0 \ 7.5 \ 7.5

MCMiles ………. 4.0 \ 7.0 \ 7.0

qualitycomix ………. 3.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

october ………. 4.5 \ 8.0 \ 8.0

agro23 ………. 3.5 \ 6.5 \ 7.5

nik ………. 4.0 \ 7.5 \ 7.0

trmoore54 ………. 4.5 \ 7.0 \ 7.0

topofthetotem ………. 3.5 \ 8.0 \ 7.5

comicdey ………. 5.0 \ 7.5 \ 7.5

[font:Impact]Warlord ………. 5.0 \ 8.0 \8.0 [/font]

comicdonna ………. 4.0 \ 6.0 \ 7.0

Buck Biggins ………. 5.0 \ 8.5 \ 8.0

silverage12c ………. 4.0 \ 7.0 \ 7.5

Sal ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

tatterdemalion ………. 4.0 \ 8.5 \ 7.0

catrick339 ………. 4.5 \ 7.0 \ 8.5

hellblazer ………. 5.0 \ 8.0 \8.5

CAP_Ffreek ………. 3.5 \ 7.0 \ 6.0

thedude ………. 5.0 \ 6.5 \ 8.0

Theagenes ………. 3.5 \ 7.0 \ 6.5

mrwoogieman ………. 3.5 \ 6.0 \ 7.0

143ksk ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 8.0

Aces ………. 4.0 \ 8.0 \7.5

scheradon ………. 4.5 \ 7.5 \ 7.0

LordRahl ………. 4.0 \ 8.5 \ 7.5

Kenkoy ………. 4.0 \ 5.0 \ 6.5

Osborn_fr ……….4.0\7.5\ 8.0

Toro…………4.5\7.0\7.5

Mac Man………..4.5\6.5\7.0

Burntboy……….4.5\7.5\ 8.0

Hepcat…………3.5\7.5\8.5

pastand presentcomics………..3.0\5.0\7.0

Count…….3.0\6.0\6.5

Piper……..4.5\7.0\ 8.0

Inconceivable…….. 5.5 \7.5\8.5

Paris-Fred……..3.5\4.5\6.5

Drummy………….4.0\ 8.0 \7.5

AlexH……..5.0\7.5\ 8.0

 

[Buck Biggins]

47 forum members graded the books and not a single winner.

 

Looks like Warlord was the closest but no cigar. Missed the Superman by .5!

 

October was second with 2 right guesses. Missed the Superman by 1.0

 

Only one person guess the Superman correct - Inconceivable was that forum member. Though book to grade.

 

[font:Lucida Console] THANKS FOR PLAYING FOLKS and I"M HAPPY WITH RESULTS![/font]

[Buck Biggins]

Will be sending in another 3 in late January and when its a week out from being graded we'll do this again. It was fun and maybe next time we'll get a winner.

[Point Five]

 

[font:Lucida Console] THANKS FOR PLAYING FOLKS and I"M HAPPY WITH RESULTS![/font]

[october]

October was second with 2 right guesses. Missed the Superman by 1.0

 

 

Nice grade on the Supes!