Grading Contest Results: ROUND 4

[sckao]

Winter 2007/2008 Grading Contest Results - Round 4

 

Actual Grade for Round 4: CGC 8.0

 

 

Alternate Link to Abbreviated Results:

 

http://www.splastic.com/Grading-Contest/Round4.gif

 

Alternate Link to FULL Results:

 

http://www.splastic.com/Grading-Contest/Round4b.gif

 

Scoring System

 

Contest will be 20 rounds. 48 hours between rounds, and person with the most points wins after 20 rounds.

 

Points are as follows:

 

5 - correct grade

 

3 - 1 grade off

 

1 - 2 grades off

 

-1 - 3 grades off.

 

-2 - 4 grades off

 

 

 

 

[THE_BEYONDER]

10 out of a possible 20

[Scheradon]

Crud! I gave it an 8.5. I wasn't really sure how CGC would count the pen date on the cover and the back cover soiling...I guess they hit it a little harder than I thought they would.

[He11blazer]

Reality reasserts itself once more

[joeypost]

10 out of a possible 20

 

8 out of a possible 20

 

[Pirate]

some surprises in the "i really suck at grading" standings

[Aces]

Log jam at 4th...

[MrBedrock]

some surprises in the "i really suck at grading" standings

If undergrading is a disease, I am very contagious!

I am just learning of the mythical Nik Bump.

[piper]

9 points in 3 rounds.

 

I sure wish that I hadn't missed the first round!

[EastCoastExchange-migratio]

D*NM I wish I had remembered to vote 2nd round!!

[Fan4Fan]

9 points in 3 rounds.

 

I sure wish that I hadn't missed the first round!

 

9 points in 3 rounds.

 

I sure wish that I hadn't voted the last round!

[djpinkpanther67]

[evilsly]

2 correct, 1 overgraded by .2, 1 undergraded by .2

 

not bad

 

 

[Goonchild-migration]

2 correct, 1 overgraded by .2, 1 undergraded by .2

 

not bad

 

 

Self-praise is no recommendation

 

Mind you that's easy for me to say, having entered all 4 rounds so far, and worked my way up to ZERO

[silverage12c]

Mind you that's easy for me to say, having entered all 4 rounds so far, and worked my way up to ZERO

[Aces]

2 correct, 1 overgraded by .2, 1 undergraded by .2

 

not bad

 

You've been targeted.

[toro]

Okay dj and moloch, I think someone is looking at someone else's paper.

 

[djpinkpanther67]

Okay dj and moloch, I think someone is looking at someone else's paper.

 

Don't worry - I will jack a couple up before all is said and done

[divad]

Don't worry - I will jack a couple up before all is said and done

 

No doubt.

[trmoore54]

Nik...it's apparently within the rules to abstain from voting on any given book (presumably one you're having trouble pegging...) Is there a maximum number of abstentions, or said the other way, a minmum number of entries to qualify in the final standings?

 

Seems like there should be...