PGM AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #33

[oakman29]

 

[Monstro]

already been graded?

[djpinkpanther67]

VF+ to VF/NM Very sweet copy!!!

[marvelcollector]

Is that some kind of blemish on the FC, near one of the splashes?

[oakman29]

No blemishes maybe on CGC case I want know if I should get this book re-subbed,I don't want anyone to know grade as of yet,it could sway people to grade differently.

[marvelcollector]

I'd say 8.0....

Is it for sale?

[djpinkpanther67]

CGC must have given it a 7.5 or 8.0

[Dark Knight]

I'd say 9.0

[oakman29]

No not for sale.

[fishbone]

I have an 8.0 , but this looks much sharper..............8.5 - 9.0??? And it's THE best Ditko cover IMO

[trmoore54]

I have an 8.0 , but this looks much sharper..............8.5 - 9.0??? And it's THE best Ditko cover IMO

 

Easy 9.0 IMO...yes, my favorite ASM cover of ALL TIME! NICE BOOK! (thumbs u

[JohnT]

I'd go 9.2. Very sharp cut on this book, and all I see is the one spine stress line and a couple of spine ticks.

[oakman29]

here is the grade should I resubbmit or is it an 8.5 for sure?

 

[trmoore54]

I'da been really pizzed if I sent that in and got an 8.5...however, obviously, there's no guarantee it'll come back a 9.0 but I'd probably go for it...

[TFL-migration]

That is not an 8.5 book. Unless you want to sell it too me. From the scans I'd go a minimum of 9.0 Possible 9.2 Buy the book. Not the slab, really does apply here.

[nik]

here is the grade should I resubbmit or is it an 8.5 for sure?

 

 

No

[rodan57]

Just some thoughts:

 

8.5 is a threshold grade. A lot of 8.5s look really really good.

 

There are two spots (rust transfer/stain?) near the top staple on the back that might have hurt the grade, or perhaps the lower left edge of the back cover where the scan hints at an edge bend or associated roughness.

 

You might need to turn the book on an angle to see any dents or subtle bends -- and anything inside (page tears/stains/writing) is of course hidden.

 

If none of the above apply you should call for grader's notes to see if one of the three graders gave the book a 9.0.

[oakman29]

Thats a great idea I'm going to call on the graders notes on Monday.I bought this book not because of the grade on the slab,but because it looks beautiful in hand and knew this could not be an 8.5.I thought for sure at least 9.0/9.2 sharp corners,no Marvel chipping(you almost always find on this book),staples are perfect.I don't know.

[JohnT]

It's very hard to grade books from scans. Just because we think the book should be higher, that doesn't mean we're right. There almost has to be more to the story, and the graders notes will probably tell you what it is.