Giant Size X-Men #1

[maloney414]

I know what CGC says, but I'm curious what others think.

 

[JohnT]

I think it's dark.

[oakman29]

is there any chance of getting a scan? Its too dark to get any idea of flaws etc.

[oakman29]

Stab in the dark ! 8.0

[Timmay]

9.2 b/c of aee scan

[50 Cent #II (1st)]

Somewhere between 7.0-9.2. Provide a scan an I will narrow it down.

[maloney414]

Sorry about the picture. I just put it on my scanner, so here's another pic.

 

[JohnT]

 

Keep trying!

[oakman29]

WOW even your scanner is dark?

CGC for some reason is very harsh on these books.I have a GS X-MEN #1 that looks like a 9.4 but they gave it a 9.0 .I think I'll stick with my previous decision 8.0

[TFL-migration]

Still a dark scan. But I will say 8.5

[gernblanston]

No way to tell on that one especially with the white cover.

[oakman29]

Whats the grade? I'm dying to know.

[maloney414]

Officially, it's a 7.0

 

I know my scans aren't great, but it looks really nice to me. I was thinking it was possibly undergraded.

 

I have no intention of selling it, so I'm not going to resubmit it. I was just curious if my opinion was accurate and wanted to get some 2nd opinions.

 

 

[TFL-migration]

While it's hard to see the book and it's flaws. With no back cover scan it is a bit of a guess. But it looks under graded to me.

[gernblanston]

You could always play the resub lottery. Usually the new grade is within 1 grade of the first so you would have a great shot at 7.5

[CAP Freak]

7.0