Matthew McConaughey possible Captain America

[Mac Man]

Good idea Kev! I was personally voting for Aaron Eckhardt (sp?), but he'll be our new Two Face

[The Black Hand ®]

McConaughey?

 

Seems more like a loverboy than the all-American hero. This will be a tough role to fill.

 

Too bad Chuck Norris wasn't twenty years younger.

 

[bronze_rules]

I've always thought that this guy would be the perfect Cap, especially after seeing him in the WW2 mini Band of Brothers, but he's also been in movies like Walking Tall & Minority Report:

 

Neal McDonough

 

I could see it. His role in the guardian is a perfect character emulation.

 

[Big Daddy]

What about Brad Pitt or Matt Damon? I know they are mega stars but they would probably rock the part.

[Monstro]

i think it should be more about character then how the actor looks in the Cap's uniform.

whoever it is needs to have a very commanding presence.

 

 

[seanfingh]

 

That's an interesting point. How will they handle the skinny/scrawny pre-serum Steve Rogers morphing into the buffed out CA. They could get Ed Norton to beef up like he did in American History X, but he's already Bruce Banner. Is it feasible for someone to skinny to get the part and then pack lbs. of muscle on a la Tobey Maguire?

[Rommin]

Would McConuaghey be any worse than this?

 

 

 

Is that the movie that Cap picked up the motorcycle, threw it over the 15' fence, had it land on both tires and stay standing up?

[Dollarbill]

I think the kid from Starship Troopers that played Johhny Rico would be ideal for the role, as far as looks go.But I can't for the life of me remember his name.

[TheBrockley]

I think the kid from Starship Troopers that played Johhny Rico would be ideal for the role, as far as looks go.But I can't for the life of me remember his name.

 

Casper Van Dien

[CAP Freak]

Matt Damon...

 

[CAP Freak]

More importantly... How about Val Kilmer as Thor?

 

[EastCoastExchange-migratio]

He over acts in all of his movies. I hate every movie he's ever been in. Why him?

[TupennyConan]

Matt Damon...

 

 

I'm not saying this is who I'd choose, but my money is on Damon landing the part.

 

Prediction made right here!

[TupennyConan]

He over acts in all of his movies. I hate every movie he's ever been in. Why him?

 

I hate him more than you do.

[EastCoastExchange-migratio]

More importantly... How about Val Kilmer as Thor?

 

 

ICE

[TFL-migration]

Get Brock Lesnar too do it.... If he can act in the WWE and get his butt kicked in the UFC, He'd be a good Cap.......

[CAP Freak]

He over acts in all of his movies. I hate every movie he's ever been in. Why him?

He looks like Thor, kind of?

[EastCoastExchange-migratio]

He over acts in all of his movies. I hate every movie he's ever been in. Why him?

He looks like Thor, kind of?

 

[Mac Man]

More importantly... How about Val Kilmer as Thor?

 

 

I always love telling the story of when I was the XO in my Battalion's Rear Detachment, I put his cousin (second or third cousin, I believe) in high-security military prison for deserting. He used to brag how he was related to Val. Didn't really work for him though.

 

Fella was a real piece of work--no reflection on Val, of course.

 

I'd be happy with Matt Damon. I don't think his personality would overpower the character.

[CKB]

Toughest guy I've seen on screen in a long time was Daniel Craig in the last Bond movie. Of course he's out of the running purely on principle...

 

We need Vincent D'onofrio to reprise his role as Thor from Adventures in Babysitting. Unfortunately he's suffering from a fatal case of BDS (and KFC for that matter).