PGM Tales of Suspense #59

[MSParkinson]

Ok, i've got the PGM thing down now

Can someone suggest a grading for this copy of TOS 59? I only scanned the front but i will scan the backs on future comics..

 

[mysterymachine]

looks to be 5.0 from the front.

[oakman29]

I think it's closer to a 6.0/6.5 very good eye appeal (thumbs u

[TFL-migration]

If the BC is as nice as the FC I will say 7.5 Possible 8.0 in hand IMHO 5.0?? Errrrrrrrrrr

I'd take 5.0's like that all day long!!

[MSParkinson]

yeah, 5.0 seems a little harsh - seems pretty nice to me

thanks btw.

[Mr.Diggler]

I'm thinking 6.5 or so as well. WAY to many dings for an 8.0 IMHO

[MSParkinson]

6.5 would work for me..

[tsarax]

If the BC is as nice as the FC I will say 7.5 Possible 8.0 in hand IMHO 5.0?? Errrrrrrrrrr

I'd take 5.0's like that all day long!!

 

I guess we are in the same boat, because I was thinking 8.0 myself.

 

[Comicdey]

6.0

[Mr.Diggler]

all over the place on this one.

[joeypost]

7.0/7.5

[comic_lot]

7.0/7.5

 

Ditto.

[Mutie Fan]

6.5-7.0

[MSParkinson]

All over the place is right..i wodner what about it makes such a difference in opinion - i dont know much about grading but isnt 5.0-8.0 quite a large difference?

[JWKyle]

I would have to say 7.0 if the back looks as good as the front. It may be all over the place because it is a light cover and the flaws are a little harder to see. I just bought a vg+ a little while ago and i wished it looked this good. Nice Book

 

P.s Throw out the low and the high and I think your grade will average out more evenly.

 

[ROBTOTHEC]

If you look closely at the spine and near the bottom there is too much going on there IMO to grade higher than a 6.0! MSParkinson, like in skating take out the highs and low scores and see what you are averaging after that. These scans can look different on different peoples computers. Some pick up detail better. GOOD LUCK!