PGM: Comic Calvacade #2

[Jeffreykli]

Opinions, please.

 

 

 

Defects that you can't see from the scan are:

 

1. 1.5" spine split at bottom

2. 1' spine split at top

3. a tear on an interior page

4. Cover detached

5. First 4 pages missing!

 

Based on the first 4 pages missing, would you just grade the book as incomplete, and move on?

 

Thanks,

Jeff

[Extremo Man-migration]

Mmm... 1.5 - 2

[pinball]

Bummer about the missing pages.

 

2.0 if not for the missing pages.

 

1.0 maybe

[CAP Freak]

GLOD 1.8

[rjpb]

.5

[mysterymachine]

Everything was ok until you said first 4 pages missing.

 

1.0

[Primetime]

If the pages weren't missing, it's a GD- (1.8) tops...CGC would probably say 1.5.

Otherwise, it's technical grade is a PR (.5)