All Winners #19

[lhcomics]

I just recently picked this up. Let me get some opinions on this comics grade. Off-white pages, centerfold detached at top staple but attached at bottom staple, cover fairly well attached at both staples, 1" rough tear at top of spine, piece out top back cover.

 

Off to dinner and will check opinions later.

 

Thanks Leroy

 

[Paratrooper]

2.0

[Twistty1]

1.8...

[143ksk]

2.0

 

(thumbs u

[TFL-migration]

1.8 Possible 2.0 In hand IMHO...

[CAP Freak]

:takeit:

 

1.5

[Count]

2.0

[snitzer]

love seeing GA material in here. my gut reaction was 2.0.

[lhcomics]

I agree with 2.0. It might stretch to a 2.5, either way .5 don't mean much on this comic in low grade.

 

If it were to sell it would bring above graded guide anyway.

 

Thanks for the input.

 

Leroy

[Silver Surfer]

Might have a chance at a 2.5, but at least a 2.0 for sure. If the pages are slightly brittle it could get hammer down to a 1.8. Nice copy.

[Limited66]

1.8

[Silver Surfer]

I'm surprised at all the 1.8's, if PQ is cream or better this is easily a 2.0?

[Point Five]

I agree. With a cover image this bright and clean, a cakewalk to 2.0 and even a 2.5 wouldn't shock me. Nice one!

[snitzer]

I agree with 2.0. It might stretch to a 2.5, either way .5 don't mean much on this comic in low grade.

 

If it were to sell it would bring above graded guide anyway.

 

Thanks for the input.

 

Leroy

 

agreed. for some reason, I always think of Storm Shadow from G.I. Joe when see this cover

[MagnetoWasRight]

1.8 IMHO

[JesterSB]

2.0 to me

[G.A.tor]

cgc will give a 2.5

[Silver Surfer]

Here's a couple of books I had graded just for comparison purposes:

Never submitted this one:

 

[Bunky Brian]

IMHO

 

Gd-

 

B

[lhcomics]

Defects on the All Winners are comparable the the Adventure 79 graded at 2.5 but like I said in the earlier post value between a 2.0 and 2.5 means very little on a comic like this that rarely shows up.

 

Very cool CGC comics Surfer dude!

 

Leroy