PGM X-Men # 1

[BlissComics]

 

Thinking about purchasing this one, but this is the only picture I currently have of this book.

 

Thanks for looking.

 

[kapowcat-migration]

ballpark 3.5 my opinion from picture only!

[kapowcat-migration]

from picture only my ballpark 3.5,again just picture!

[Tim's Freedom]

Here's an X-Men #1 that I have... what would you grade this?

 

 

sorry about the bag

[Point Five]

Here's an X-Men #1 that I have... what would you grade this?

 

 

sorry about the bag

Start a new thread for your book!... and we would need much better photos to even try to grade.

[Point Five]

Thinking about purchasing this one, but this is the only picture I currently have of this book.

 

Thanks for looking.

Honestly, not knowing anything about who the seller is, I can't help being wary of this scan. Is the book really this bright, even with what seems to be edge wear and chips along the bottom edge, and reading creases near the spine? Also, the green colors of the ULC box and the other box seem quite faded or washed out compared to other copies of the book...but the red in the logo seems incredibly vibrant. From the scan it looks like a real nice copy, but if this book is in an auction and this scan is all the info you have to go on, I'd be cautious.

[backtomarvel]

Agreed. If you were buying a $10 book sure, but if you're looking for advice on which is better on a key grail-type book then we need better source material to help with such a lucky problem

[Limited66]

3.5

[rodan57]

I'd be cautious about that top edge. It looks perfectly straight on a book that is otherwise worn. I'd also be a bit cautious about that right edge.

[TSwift25]

VG-, but it looks like the scan has been sharpened; that would make me a little uncomfortable, unless you already have established business with the seller.

[JohnT]

I was thinking 5.5 or so until I got to the bottom. That's some serious wear there, dropping it to 3.5 or so. But it has good eye appeal.

[TFL-migration]

3.5 IMHO The picture has been doctored by the look's of it. Ask for bigger, non enhanced images. I'd be a careful with a book like this. Why the need to alter the image??? Something has my Spidey sense tingling in regards with this book...

[MagnetoWasRight]

3.5/4.0...awesome book!

[kapowcat-migration]

looks like a 3.5 poss.4.0 ballpark.the lower damage makes me think 3.5 however??