March Madness Grading Tournament- Seeding Round

[Aces]

2. Grades are due by midnight March 6th.

 

Your time I hope which is still an hour from now you west coast dude.

 

 

Grades sent.

[Nostalgic Attic]

...tallying the scores...

[Nostalgic Attic]

Thanks to Aces we have an even 40 teams!

[Shark]

[Nostalgic Attic]

Before we get going, I wanted to express a big thanks to eveyone who is playing .

 

This is alot of fun for me too.

 

Here are the Grades:

 

Amazing Spider-Man 106 8.5

Amazing Spider-Man 133 9.2

Amazing Spider-Man 144 9.2

Amazing Spider-Man 313 9.8

Avengers 100 7.5

Batman Family 10 9.6

Daredevil 145 9.6

Defenders 38 9.6

Iron Fist 10 9.4

Incredible hulk 140 8.0

Tales To Astonish 101 8.5

Watchmen 1 9.0

 

Also, I need to clarify the scoring, my first post was a bit confusing:

 

Spot on= 2 wins

Within .5= 1 win

Not within .5 = 1 loss

Bonus: 1 extra win for the third and fourth spot on grade. 2 extra wins for the fifth and sixth spot on grade, and 3 extra wins thereafter.

[Nostalgic Attic]

The Coach's Poll is in

 

 

The top ranking goes to ffcomics at an astounding 22-2

 

This is preliminary- check your records and your regions and please PM me with any corrections. I will post the final poll later today.

 

 

1 ffcomics NE 22- 2

2 Warlord NE 19- 2

3 CheezyWhizNE 17- 1

4 SolitaireOneNE 19- 3

5 Divad NW 15- 1

6 Abracadabra 15- 1

7 shark2557 NW 17- 4

8 skao SW 15- 3

9 Jeffrykli 15- 3

10 Toro NE 14- 2

11 Almoe SE 14- 2

12 Cap Freek SW 16- 5

13 Mrwoogieman 13- 3

14 TSwift25 13- 3

15 Comicdey NW 13- 3

16 Inconceivable 13- 3

17 Gregreece NE 12- 2

18 Aces NE 12- 2

19 BlowupthemoonNE 13- 5

20 Timmay NE 13- 5

21 Drewincanada 13- 5

22 trmoore54 SW 12- 4

23 The Resurrection 12- 4

24 Jazzman NW 12- 4

25 Canickus SW 12- 4

26 BenchwarmerNE 11- 3

27 SNiPER SW 11- 3

28 TVanderZwaag 11- 3

29 thirdgreenhamNE 10- 3

30 General ZodSW 11- 5

31 comicdonnaNE 11- 5

32 Mr. SilvestriNW 11- 6

33 Hellblazer NW 10- 4

34 Cimm SE 10- 4

35 Xsmanx 10- 4

36 DJPinkpantherSW 10- 4

37 Whisp NE 10- 4

38 JohnT 9- 4

39 DollarBill 9- 5

40 AJD 8- 5

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Timmmmay

 

[Mr.Silvestri]

The Coach's Poll is in

 

 

The top ranking goes to ffcomics at an astounding 22-2

 

This is preliminary- check your records and your regions and please PM me with any corrections. I will post the final poll later today.

 

 

1 ffcomics NE 22- 2

2 Warlord NE 19- 2

3 CheezyWhizNE 17- 1

4 SolitaireOne 19- 3

5 Divad NW 15- 1

6 Abracadabra 15- 1

7 shark2557 NW 17- 4

8 skao SW 15- 3

9 Jeffrykli 15- 3

10 Toro NE 14- 2

11 Almoe SE 14- 2

12 Cap Freek SW 16- 5

13 Mrwoogieman 13- 3

14 TSwift25 13- 3

15 Comicdey NW 13- 3

16 Inconceivable 13- 3

17 Gregreece NE 12- 2

18 Aces NE 12- 2

19 BlowupthemoonNE 13- 5

20 Timmay NE 13- 5

21 Drewincanada 13- 5

22 trmoore54 SW 12- 4

23 The Resurrection 12- 4

24 Jazzman NW 12- 4

25 Canickus SW 12- 4

26 BenchwarmerNE 11- 3

27 SNiPER 11- 3

28 Tvanderswaag 11- 3

29 ThirdgreenhamNE 10- 3

30 General ZodSW 11- 5

31 comicdonnaNE 11- 5

32 Mr. SilvestriNW 11- 6

33 Hellblazer NW 10- 4

34 Cimm SE 10- 4

35 Xsmanx 10- 4

36 DJPinkpantherSW 10- 4

37 Whisp NE 10- 4

38 JohnT 9- 4

39 DollarBill 9- 5

40 AJD 8- 5

[s-man]

Avengers 100 7.5

 

Ok....what did I miss on this book??? Is there some interior damage that I was unaware of, cuz the book looks 9.? to me!

 

(Maybe I need glasses )

[JazzMan]

Avengers 100 7.5

 

Ok....what did I miss on this book??? Is there some interior damage that I was unaware of, cuz the book looks 9.? to me!

 

(Maybe I need glasses )

 

Yeah, no kidding. I was thinking the same. Sure looked a lot better than a 7.5. :doh:

[BlowUpTheMoon]

It's good to see that we are all way above .500

[Timmay]

Timmmmay

 

 

[Timmay]

 

Also, I need to clarify the scoring, my first post was a bit confusing:

 

Spot on= 2 wins

Within .5= 1 win

Not within .5 = 1 loss

Bonus: 1 extra win for the third and fourth spot on grade. 2 extra wins for the fourth and fifth spot on grade, and 3 extra wins thereafter.

 

 

still confused about the bonus

[CheezyWhiz]

Avengers 100 7.5

 

Ok....what did I miss on this book??? Is there some interior damage that I was unaware of, cuz the book looks 9.? to me!

 

(Maybe I need glasses )

 

Yeah, no kidding. I was thinking the same. Sure looked a lot better than a 7.5. :doh:

 

Has a CB corner crease in the upper right and a hard-to-see crunch to the bottom LL corner. I guessed 8.0 on that one.

[Nostalgic Attic]

 

Also, I need to clarify the scoring, my first post was a bit confusing:

 

Spot on= 2 wins

Within .5= 1 win

Not within .5 = 1 loss

Bonus: 1 extra win for the third and fourth spot on grade. 2 extra wins for the fifth and sixth spot on grade, and 3 extra wins thereafter.

 

 

still confused about the bonus

 

...just seeing if everyone was paying attention...fixed it.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Timmmmay

 

 

 

The way I am looking at things, it's gonna be me vs. you

[Timmay]

 

when does this start?

[TVanderZwaag]

TVanderswaag=TVanderZwaag?

[Shark]

TVanderzwaag=TVanderZwaag?

 

Naaawww...must be somebody else.

[Nostalgic Attic]

Avengers 100 7.5

 

Ok....what did I miss on this book??? Is there some interior damage that I was unaware of, cuz the book looks 9.? to me!

 

(Maybe I need glasses )

 

Yeah, no kidding. I was thinking the same. Sure looked a lot better than a 7.5. :doh:

 

Has a CB corner crease in the upper right and a hard-to-see crunch to the bottom LL corner. I guessed 8.0 on that one.

 

The UR Corner crease really keeps it out of 8.5 territory...not sure how the miscut affects the grade. This one was problematic for most- the average grade it got was an 8.7