PGM Adventure 289 - embarrased!

[Whitey]

Boy I'm embarrased!I posted this yesterday in the forum for grading coins.

Anyway, I would still like your opinions. Here is my original post.

 

Just purchased today from a fellow locally. I'm happy with what I paid and I believe he made some money as well. Thanks Mike!

So I'm trying to grade this but not sure what to do about the slight water damage to the front upper left corner.

slight spine roll, a little bit of spine wear.

I would like to say 5.5, (optimistic?) but I'm afraid the water damage would drop to 4.0.

I'm still happy with it, but would like to know your opinions.

 

Thanks.

 

 

[ft88]

I'd give it a 3.5 to 4 with that rather large stain up top. It'd probably rate higher than 5.5 without that.

[Boozad]

4.5

[Limited66]

4.0 (water stain)

[slym2none]

Yeah, the water stain does it in, otherwise, nice book!

 

4.0-4.5

 

 

 

-slym

[MagnetoWasRight]

4.5...

[Old Fashion PB and J]

4.0 and that is that!

[thehumantorch]

4.0 at best. Nice book though, gotta love those silly DC covers.

 

Question of the day, what grade did the coin guys give it?

[JohnT]

4.5

[Whitey]

4.0 at best. Nice book though, gotta love those silly DC covers.

 

Question of the day, what grade did the coin guys give it?

 

Well, djpinkpanther67 laughed at me, so that's why I was embarrased. There's not much action in that forum so no one kidded me too much.

 

Whitey

[slym2none]

A name like that, you wouldn't think he had much room to laugh...

 

 

 

 

-slym (he keeds, he keeds)

[TFL-migration]

4.0 IMHO

[Sekowskyfan10]

4.0. Love that ish, got a 4.0-4.5 of it myself.