How did I do on this trade (Silver age Avengers)

[Jonah Hex]

Just curious as to the overall feeling on this trade/deal I completed yesterday.

 

I traded a ...

-All Star Western #10 G/G+

-Tomb of Dracula #2 VG

Tomb of Dracula #3 VF-

-A.S.M #121 VF

-and £125 cash (About 200 US)

 

For Avengers #2,3,5,6,7 (all G/VG)

#8,9,10,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,23,24,25,26,44(all at least VG)

 

I had multiples of the All Star #10 and the ASM 121 so it was not cutting into my main collection. I'm starting to think I overpaid/traded.

What does the board think??

 

[bronze_rules]

I'd take your original collection, but that's just me.

Especially, considering you paid $200 (USD) on top of that, it doesn't sound too equitable.

[sckao]

 

Not a good trade IMO.... but okay if you really wanted the Avengers. (thumbs u

 

 

[Bosco685]

The cash is what killed this trade from being a win overall, IMHO.

[Jonah Hex]

The cash is what killed this trade from being a win overall, IMHO.

 

Its actually £125 worth of credits toward my stuff in a future deal. We go back and forth like this. I think I win most of them but maybe my subconscience guilt let him get away with this one!

I'll have to overcharge him next time!

As I said the comics I gave up were my 3'rd and 4'th copies respectively, so I'm happy.

Thanks for the input though. Its great to hear impartial perspectives....

[jimjum12]

You're probably going to enjoy the Avengers more....and there was nothing irreplaceable in the stuff you traded....I wouldn't sweat it, kick back and enjoy your books. GOD BLESS...

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus) (thumbs u

[kidcolt]

I would rather what you gave up

 

All Star Western #10 G/G+

-Tomb of Dracula #2 VG

Tomb of Dracula #3 VF-

-A.S.M #121 VF

-and £125 cash (About 200 US)

 

 

But really who cares what I think, as long as you are happy with your trade.

[PUNYHUMAN]

I don't know about the $200 cash , but if it's for trading later , cool.

As long as your happy with the trade that's all that counts.

BTW those Avengers issues are some great reads and art...

Enjoy!!

[supapimp]

you got hosed, man.

[thehumantorch]

Good trade.

[Unca Ben]

It would be a bad trade if you believe $$ = enjoyment.

It's a good trade if you enjoy Kirby/Lee silver age stories.

[nmtg9]

Well Jonah if you're happy with the trade then you done good. (thumbs u

 

Personally I would rather have the Avengers, but I dont collect comics for monetary value at all.