PGM FF 52 (sending this off to CGC.. test your skills!)

[joeypost]

No tear at top back cover

 

[oakman29]

Im telling you there is no tear,it's a little darker in that area due to some wear.

This why I DO NOT SELL COMIC BOOKS and from now on will not be trading books either.I just buy books and have stayed out of the seller/dealer ring for 30 years,why should I change now

[zuckuss2003]

Maybe a closer picture would help, It does look like a tear. Even excluding that, I see it a stretch for an 8.0 let alone an 8.5/9.0 The top FC also looks like it has issues but this is a very nice looking book nonetheless

[Dick Pontoon]

7.5

 

The beginning of foxing is widespread on the BC.

 

It looks more like tanning and maybe soiling to me, hard to tell from the scan. I'd also probably say 7.5.

 

That looks like a tear to me, too, on the BC.

[c-mack]

Im telling you there is no tear,it's a little darker in that area due to some wear.

This why I DO NOT SELL COMIC BOOKS and from now on will not be trading books either.I just buy books and have stayed out of the seller/dealer ring for 30 years,why should I change now

 

hey buddy dont worry about it, i just made this as something fun to do....i agree with you in our convo......i think the book is what you told me and im not worried at all in fact i just saw some 9.0 look pretty damn close to this book so im pretty stoked! about getting this...

 

=) (thumbs u

[MagnetoWasRight]

8.0/8.5 IMHO

[c-mack]

book was dropped off at bedrockcity tonight and i paid for the express service so i should have it back in a week or so

 

so get your grades in =)

[Timmay]

ill be sending this off pretty soon so if you would like to test your skills be my guess!

 

 

[c-mack]

[Timmay]

7.5

[LloydJBailey]

From the pictures, i'd give it an 8.0, maybe an 8.5... but scans don't do comics justice. From the scan, i'd bet my money on an 8.0.

[DCman]

7.5

 

[mschmidt]

7.5, possibly an 8.0 on a good day

[joeypost]

[universal soldier]

I'm going to play it safe and go with an 8.0 on this. That top edge gives me pause...

[ARK]

7.5 The top edges of both the FC & BC have too much going on.

[The Silver-Age]

Any update on this?

[c-mack]

yeah bedrockcity sent it off late due to being out of forms...i have to call to see if its been mailed off...but shouldnt be long since i paid for express

[The Silver-Age]

Right on

[c-mack]

looks like it wont be sent off till the end of this week =( cgc still hasnt sent them more forms