What's the Blue Label grade of this book?

[drbanner]

What's the grade of this book if some kid had scribbled his name on it back in the day instead of Stan the Man, 6.0 or so?

 

Avengers 4 9.2 SS

 

[Mio]

8.5

[DiceX]

Did the kid draw a big assed cockroach on it, too?

 

 

[seanfingh]

 

Who wound up Mike today?

[pickycollector]

 

Kid's inks or Stan's inks, that is still ink added to the cover, isn't it ?

[DrWatson]

Yea! Another "What I collect is great and what you collect sucks" thread.

 

[topofthetotem]

In all honesty you can't accurately grade a book from a scan.

[VintageComics]

What's the grade of this book if some kid had scribbled his name on it back in the day instead of Stan the Man, 6.0 or so?

 

Avengers 4 9.2 SS

 

 

Might grade a little higher than 6.0 blue because the ink is not as obtrusive as if it was black in on the white cover stock.

 

I'd say 7.0 range.

 

That's a board member's book if I'm not mistaken.

[seanfingh]

Yea! Another "What I collect is great and what you collect sucks" thread.

 

 

I give Mike wide latitude, but it is starting to look that way.

[Guardian Comics]

But it is not signed by Johnny McComic so what is the point of the thread? Looks like a pretty strong 9.2 actually judging by the bottom left hand corner.

 

Jim

[seanfingh]

 

Merely insuring the continued life of this thread. This has been a public service announcement from the Fingh.

[MutantKeys]

The label says 9.2

[Silver Surfer]

Signature is well placed but it always pains me to see high grade copies like this get scribbled on. Just not my cup of tea.

[Mr 9.8]

Signature is well placed but it always pains me to see high grade copies like this get scribbled on. Just not my cup of tea.

+1

[Jaymole]

Well, that's one less book that will tempt and frustrate me in not owning it.

[Old Fashion PB and J]

At least its a book he actually wrote. But I would like a 7.0 SS and a 9.2 blue better. My opinion though, and I dont care for the sig placement.

[seanfingh]

 

I think Arch or Dena should just sticky one of the "I hate high grade Silver Age SS" threads at the top of general so there doesn't need to be one every ten days.

[Old Fashion PB and J]

I think Arch or Dena should just sticky one of the "I hate high grade Silver Age SS" threads at the top of general so there doesn't need to be one every ten days.

I think they should sticky a thread that says Sean is a whiny-dork at the top as well. Kidding aside. I dont hate HG SA signature books, I do however hate the books that are obvious grabs for cash from suckers. I dont personally think I would want Stan touching that book.

[seanfingh]

I think Arch or Dena should just sticky one of the "I hate high grade Silver Age SS" threads at the top of general so there doesn't need to be one every ten days.

I think they should sticky a thread that says Sean is a whiny-dork at the top as well. Kidding aside. I dont hate HG SA signature books, I do however hate the books that are obvious grabs for cash from suckers. I dont personally think I would want Stan touching that book.

 

[LordRahl]

What's the grade of this book if some kid had scribbled his name on it back in the day instead of Stan the Man, 6.0 or so?

 

Avengers 4 9.2 SS

 

 

I don't know. What would the grade be if it was a Winnipeg pedigree and had Dennis Kjolso scribbled on it instead of Stan?