FeeBay Knuckle-head alert. 100% positive, VF+ FAIL!

[mrlatko]

I don't have the patience today to mess with or educate this 100% positive feedback FeeBay seller on comic grading, but maybe some of you feel like having some fun or doing some good by explaining to this seller that they are, um... a poor comic grader??

 

I stumbled onto this auction for a VF+ copy of Batman #210. Take a look at the back cover scan. Wow. I'm guessing that the seller is just clueless. It is too bad that some newbs will probably buy this guy's books because of his feedback.

 

Anyway, add this guy to your list of excluded sellers when searching for books:

 

Poor raw comic grader on FeeBay

 

[bug33fouf]

[Boozad]

He took a look at Round 6 of the NMGC obviously.

[mschmidt]

Wow. Even for eBay grading that's pretty crazy. "Light staining", indeed.

[thehumantorch]

That back cover sure reveals a lot of damage. Looks like serious water damage.

Good-fair condition at best.

[Boozad]

Wow. Even for eBay grading that's pretty crazy. "Light staining", indeed.

 

Yep, the last time I saw 'light staining' like that, I had to buy new trousers.

[Shark]

I don't have the patience today to mess with or educate this 100% positive feedback FeeBay seller on comic grading, but maybe some of you feel like having some fun or doing some good by explaining to this seller that they are, um... a poor comic grader??

 

I stumbled onto this auction for a VF+ copy of Batman #210. Take a look at the back cover scan. Wow. I'm guessing that the seller is just clueless. It is too bad that some newbs will probably buy this guy's books because of his feedback.

 

Anyway, add this guy to your list of excluded sellers when searching for books:

 

Poor raw comic grader on FeeBay

 

 

What a joke!

[edgerx]

Well, his grading at least seems consistent...all his other items appear overgraded as well.

[fanfourforever]

Why waste your time w/ Ebay when there is a Batman #210 CGC 9.0 up for sale on the boards right now!

[mrlatko]

Why waste your time w/ Ebay when there is a Batman #210 CGC 9.0 up for sale on the boards right now!

 

I saw your book, but I already have a CGC 9.2. Good luck with your sale though.

[dupont2005]

 

If that thing is VF I want to see his VG

[mrlatko]

Wow. Even for eBay grading that's pretty crazy. "Light staining", indeed.

 

Yep, the last time I saw 'light staining' like that, I had to buy new trousers.

 

 

[Conan_Aficionado]

this gives me hope that i might actually have some 9.8s in my collection, prior to this my best guess was that I would be lucky to find 1 out of 1000 in the 9.4 range.

[Comicopolis]

Too funny for words.

 

Well, just a few words.

 

 

[oakman29]

I don't know? the 7.0 Tomahawk in the grading game looked worse,just sayin'

[DR.X]

That back cover sure reveals a lot of damage. Looks like serious water damage.

Good-fair condition at best.

 

Looks like the dog too a whiz on it.

 

DR.X

[Cimm]

Check out his "NM+" Detective Comics #500... inch and a half horizontal tear through spine in upper left... it can be yours for only 750.00

[Conan]

This is why I look for sellers with clear scans and good descriptions. If I still have questions, I send them a message.

 

I know very little about grading, but even I know that those grades are way too high, just by looking at the scans!

 

[bronze_rules]

Looks like it came from the bronze_rules bathtub pedigree!

 

 

does that mean my copy qualifies as an 8.5??

[DR.X]

Check out his "NM+" Detective Comics #500... inch and a half horizontal tear through spine in upper left... it can be yours for only 750.00

 

Check out the feedback on the Batman #203 VF/NM that he just sold. Look at the lower F.C. and that B.C. VF/NM? Please.

 

DR.X