Detective #164 Grade Help Please

[Smittys]

 

[bill977]

without the spine roll(if that's what is) and misplaced staples that is easily a 7.5 to me. so i would say a 6.0 or 6.5

[qualitycomix]

6.5

[The Silver-Age]

With the spine roll and the large crease on the lrc, I'd say a 5.5

 

If you are into pressing, the spine roll can be gotten rid of, but not the color braking creases. May bump it up to a 6.0

 

With those creases on the bottom right side, I cant see it grading higher than a 6.5 after all is pressed.

[rjpb]

corner crease would bring it down to 5.5 - maybe a GA bump to 6.0 as it is otherwise real pretty. Staple placement would not effect grade.

 

Cool cover.

[The_Captain]

5.5/ 6.0

[Snake Eyes]

6.0

[Sandflea]

6.5

[Comicdey]

5.5 due to the big corner crease, but as it's a black cover, CGC might be more generous than that and go 6.0

[Conan_Aficionado]

5.5/6.0