PGM Captain America Comics #54

[Kirk Kenobi]

Just picked up my first Golden Age book and would love some opinions. Made the scans nice and big. There is some tanning on the interior covers and the PQ looks to be Cream to Off-White.

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Sandflea]

Congrats on your 1st GA comic purchase; I hope to get there someday myself... (thumbs u

 

Guesstimating a 3.0/3.5...

[Kirk Kenobi]

Congrats on your 1st GA comic purchase; I hope to get there someday myself... (thumbs u

 

Guesstimating a 3.0/3.5...

 

Thanks for the congrats. I'm hoping it grades a bit higher than that.

[rabidwolf]

Very solid copy. I would say at least a 5.5 from what I see.

[generic user]

i'd be happy with that as a 4.0

[KPvD2011]

5.0 to 5.5 IMHO

[Hibou]

4.5 / 5.0

 

Very nice!

[ARK]

I'm with a 5.0 and maybe a GA bump to 5.5. Nice first GA book.

[thehumantorch]

Great book for your first GA book. Congrats.

 

5.0

[Kirk Kenobi]

Thanks everyone. I think it is going to present really well for whatever grade it receives. The front cover is striking in person.

[Point Five]

Not sure what flaws you guys see here that I'm not seeing. I'll say 6.0, maybe even a bit higher with a GA nudge. Gorgeous!

 

 

[NYNick]

Great book for your first GA book. Congrats.

 

5.0

 

(thumbs u

[Kirk Kenobi]

Not sure what flaws you guys see here that I'm not seeing. I'll say 6.0, maybe even a bit higher with a GA nudge. Gorgeous!

 

 

Thank you kind sir!

[Spiderphill]

Nice book 4.5

[rjpb]

I'd say 5.0 - wear at bottom and back cover issues keep it out of the FN range IMHO.

 

Very respectable copy with excellent eye-appeal.

[Sandflea]

Congrats on your 1st GA comic purchase; I hope to get there someday myself... (thumbs u

 

Guesstimating a 3.0/3.5...

 

Thanks for the congrats. I'm hoping it grades a bit higher than that.

 

Looking at the grading quotes from the other boardies, I'm glad I was wrong about the grade I quoted.

 

Methinks I need to learn more about grading GA books...

[Kirk Kenobi]

Congrats on your 1st GA comic purchase; I hope to get there someday myself... (thumbs u

 

Guesstimating a 3.0/3.5...

 

Thanks for the congrats. I'm hoping it grades a bit higher than that.

 

Looking at the grading quotes from the other boardies, I'm glad I was wrong about the grade I quoted.

 

Methinks I need to learn more about grading GA books...

 

This is a good place to do just that. I'm usually amazed by the collective knowledge of the folks around here.

[143ksk]

5.5