PGM Daredevil #5

[68 Birdman-migration]

Thanks for helping me out! What is the highest grade possible for a comic with a dust shadow like this one has?

 

 

[Hibou]

I'd say the book is a 7.0 maybe 7.5...

 

 

[KPvD2011]

It depends on the extent of the discoloration; to my knowledge 6.5 would be the highest grade, allowing a "slight" discoloration..... Here it is not quite "slight".... I would say 4.0

[ARK]

6.0 for me.

[Hibou]

Yeah... I think I might've been a little off on this one!

 

I just looked through the Overstreet Grading Guide and for a 7.0 they allow yellowing and tanning but that's to the interior.

 

For a 6.5, as was mentioned, slight discoloration, staining or foxing is allowed.

 

I agree that this book, unfortunately, is more than slight.

 

 

[KPvD2011]

Yeah... I think I might've been a little off on this one!

 

I just looked through the Overstreet Grading Guide and for a 7.0 they allow yellowing and tanning but that's to the interior.

 

For a 6.5, as was mentioned, slight discoloration, staining or foxing is allowed.

 

I agree that this book, unfortunately, is more than slight.

 

Otherwise a very nice copy...but the shadow just kills it for me!

[68 Birdman-migration]

Yeah... I think I might've been a little off on this one!

 

I just looked through the Overstreet Grading Guide and for a 7.0 they allow yellowing and tanning but that's to the interior.

 

For a 6.5, as was mentioned, slight discoloration, staining or foxing is allowed.

 

I agree that this book, unfortunately, is more than slight.

 

 

Although unfortunate, for a noob, this is exactly what I want to hear. It is all part of getting educated on the subject.

 

Thanks for all of the response thus far!

[Conan_Aficionado]

6.5/7.0

[ROBTOTHEC]

6.0 IMHO>!

[rabidwolf]

6.0/6.5 unless the dust shadow is really bad. I had a spidey 2 with dark tanning on all three corners. Strucutrally it was easily an 8.0. It got a 5.5 due to the heavy tanning on the borders.

[godquest]

Go with the 6.0 for me.

[The_Captain]

6.0

[Sandflea]

5.5

[KPvD2011]

It depends on the extent of the discoloration; to my knowledge 6.5 would be the highest grade, allowing a "slight" discoloration..... Here it is not quite "slight".... I would say 4.0

 

....4.0 is too harsh....5.0 after reconsideration due to the extent of the discoloration!

[asr0462]

I'm thinking 5.0. The colors fading are really there, though. Love the issue, though (big Dardedevil guy here).

[KPvD2011]

I'm always striving for consensus....... don't spoil it now

[Spiderphill]

6.0

[rodan57]

Is there tanning on the inside covers and pages?

[68 Birdman-migration]

Is there tanning on the inside covers and pages?

 

The inside pages are complete, intact, and free of defects other than yellowing.