Contest with an actual prize!!!!!

[chunkybutt]

Okay, here are the rules.

You must grade all 3 books each with 3 categories:

 

1) label ie. blue, green, purple

2) actual grade

3) page quality

 

Submission should read something like this:

54, blue 9.6 white pages

55, blue 9.2 off white/white

61, blue 9.8 white pages

 

 

You may only submit a grade one time, any edited posts will be cancelled.

I do not have back cover scans because I am an 1diot.

 

The winner will get something really cool, I do not know what it is yet.

Books are already at CGC so, grades should be coming in 5-15 days........I hope

 

And here are the books

 

Captain America Comics 54

 

Captain America Comics 55

 

Captain America Comics 61

[oakman29]

Do we PM you our answers?

[chunkybutt]

Do we PM you our answers?

 

I think just posting them would be better.

[oakman29]

54, blue 3.5 cream/off white pages

55, blue 3.0 off white pages

61, blue 4.0 off white pages

Just a stab in the dark with PQ you don't really show the pages.

[excelsior1986]

54, blue 5.0 OW

56, blue 3.0 CR/OW

61, blue 5.5 OW

 

The page quality is a lil hard to determine with no interior pics.

[chunkybutt]

54, blue 5.0 OW

56, blue 3.0 CR/OW

61, blue 5.5 OW

 

The page quality is a lil hard to determine with no interior pics.

 

I know it is my sick joke. oh BTW the prize will be a Signature Series book

[oakman29]

54, blue 5.0 OW

56, blue 3.0 CR/OW

61, blue 5.5 OW

 

The page quality is a lil hard to determine with no interior pics.

 

I know it is my sick joke. oh BTW the prize will be a Signature Series book

If I'm the only one to vote do I win by default?

[oakman29]

Is the sig. series Stan Lee,or just some doofus you want to get rid of anyway?

[Dark Knight]

I'll play..

 

54 , blue 5.0 CR/OW

56, blue 4.5 OW

61, blue 5.5 OW

[NuffSaid57]

54, blue 3.0 cream/off white

56, blue 4.5 off white

61, blue 2.5 off white

 

[Columbia Comics]

54, blue 4.0 CR/OW

55, blue 3.0 CR/OW

61, blue 4.5 OW

 

Let's get me something really cool!!

[comicdonna]

54 blue 4.0 ow/w pages

55 purple 3.0 ow/w pages

61 blue 4.0 ow pages

[porky]

54, purple, 3.0, cream/off white

55, blue, 2.5, cream/off white

61, blue, 4.0, off white

 

[Sandflea]

What the heck...I'll give it a shot...

 

54, green, 3.0, CR/OW

 

55, blue, 2.0, CR/OW

 

61, blue, 3.5, OW

[Comicdey]

54, Purple, 3.0, CR/OW, CT etc.

 

55, blue, 3.0, OW

 

61, Purple, 3.5, OW, Trimmed

 

[This is water]

Is the sig. series Stan Lee,or just some doofus you want to get rid of anyway?

 

Does it matter? It's free.

[higgsboson]

 

54 Blue 4.0 CR/OW (bottom staple detached, tape on cover, centerfold)

55 Blue 3.5 CR/OW

61 Blue 2.5 CR/OW (edges of pages are browning)

 

 

[chunkybutt]

Is the sig. series Stan Lee,or just some doofus you want to get rid of anyway?

 

 

The sig is not Stan Lee, but it is a guy who charges more for a sig than Stan does.........

[chunkybutt]

54, Purple, 3.0, CR/OW, CT etc.

 

55, blue, 3.0, OW

 

61, Purple, 3.5, OW, Trimmed

 

Damn, you are awfully harsh on the Cap books.

You must be a Batman fan?

[Junkdrawer]

3.5

3.0

3.5

all blue and COW pages