ROUND 6 : Challenge Time

[nik]

Round 5 will close in 4+ hours, so for all those members playing, post your grades.

Starting Round 6, alot of forum members have said the previous rounds were too easy, soooooo time to separate all you Hotshot contenders from the pretenders.

Books will be from 2.0 - 8.5

Points will be

 

10--- Dead On

7--- +/- .5

5--- +/- 1 Full grade

2--- +/- 1.5

So for all you KEEN graders that missed a few Rounds, time to show your skills.

 

This book has the New CGC Label with Cream-OW-Pages.

Round 6 will end on Thursday at 1:00 PM EST,

 

Good Luck

[143ksk]

I hate being first!

 

FN+ 6.5

 

Fabulous cover!

[ArAich]

5.0 ...

[Mr. Zipper]

5.0 VG/FN

 

[drbanner]

5.5

 

That's a nice, clean book for a mid-grade!

[awe4one]

6.0

 

Jim

[AlexH]

Looks nice except for the crease:

 

I will say 6.5

[osborn_fr]

5.0

 

(edited )

[Fan4Fan]

5.0

[Zanarkand]

Because of how leniently CGC grades GAs, 6.5.

[Darthdiesel]

6.0

[Silver]

6.5

[ultimatevenom]

6.0

[joe_collector]

6.5

[Darthdiesel]

Because of how leniently CGC grades GAs, 6.5.

 

Golden Age you say? then this book is a 9.4, if CGC really gave Golden Age a break

[jimm94]

nahhh, I'll stick to my guns. 6.0

[nik]

Because of how leniently CGC grades GAs, 6.5.

 

You know I hear this alot, but I will be damned, I havent been lucky enough

So in saying this, here is your only hint on this book, if you want to edit your predictions.

[Darthdiesel]

Because of how leniently CGC grades GAs, 6.5.

 

You know I hear this alot, but I will be damned, I havent been lucky enough

 

so you are saying you didn't get a 6.5 or higher on this

[FFB]

3.5

 

Niko, please make sure you note that I amended my prior answer, since you're allowing it on this book.

[NewtSamson]

I was going to say .5 grade higher than what I am about to say but then I noticed the missing right lower edge to the front cover.

I grade this a

5.5