5th Annual March Madness Grading Tournament Sweet 16

[porky]

....tallying........

 

tally in my favor! or at least put up the grades so i can see how bad i did before bed

[Nostalgic Attic]

 

 

 

[Nostalgic Attic]

Fantastic Four #95 OW-W 9.6

Fantastic Four #114 OW-W 9.0

Giant Size Defenders #5 W 9.6

Tales of Suspense #78 OW-W 9.0

 

[Nostalgic Attic]

FINAL SCORES:

 

13. Burntboy 55

8. flatrock02 50

 

7. Divad 78

11. Dice X 70

 

9. TheGeneral 58

4. Flee-Marquette 43

 

10.Blowupthemoon 62

14. Jeffreykli 63

 

1. Toro 61

4. Aces 53

 

10. Warlord 63

11.porky 60

 

1. ARK 61

12.Etanick 90

 

15. Zuckuss2003 69

14. Pirate 66

[divad]

Fantastic Four #95 OW-W 9.6

Fantastic Four #114 OW-W 9.0

Giant Size Defenders #5 W 9.6

Tales of Suspense #78 OW-W 9.0

 

Hey Dice - watcha got? Beat 78?

 

If you did, then (thumbs u

[divad]

FINAL SCORES:

 

7. Divad 78

11. Dice X 70

 

 

Smokin'

[Nostalgic Attic]

Uh...there's a problem with the scoring tabulations that affects a few games....

 

Hold on the celebrating...

[Nostalgic Attic]

...would sckao please report to the scorers table?.....

[Nostalgic Attic]

FINAL SCORES:

 

13. Burntboy 55

8. flatrock02 50

 

7. Divad 78

11. Dice X 70

 

9. TheGeneral 58

4. Flee-Marquette 43

 

10.Blowupthemoon 62

14. Jeffreykli 63

 

1. Toro 61

4. Aces 53

 

10. Warlord 63

11.porky 60

 

1. ARK 61

12.Etanick 90

 

15. Zuckuss2003 69

14. Pirate 66

 

[sckao]

...would sckao please report to the scorers table?.....

 

What happened?

 

(You changed the scoring by adding in the .2 differential and the spreadsheet array formula lookup probably didn't get totally updated...)

 

 

[Nostalgic Attic]

I apologize about the confusion.

 

I had to calculate the scores manually. There seems to be an error in the spreadsheet tabulation which gave a couple players 15 points instead of 10. Nothing I do can get it to tabulate correctly automatically.

[DiceX]

FINAL SCORES:

 

7. Divad 78

11. Dice X 70

 

 

Smokin'

 

I had the third highest score and I go home.

I changed the second book from 9.0 to 9.2 just before I hit the submit button. Luck for you.

 

Congrats. Now go represent and kick these guy's asses.

 

 

[porky]

that last 9.0 was ugly

[Flee-Marquette]

that last 9.0 was ugly

 

Tell me about it. I crashed and burned on that comic.

I spent more time this round staring at the slabs trying to figure out if it was a

scratch on the case or on the comic. Good luck to the Elite 8!

[toro]

Wow, not one bullseye this round and I still moved on. I agree with porky that is one ugly 9.0. Sometimes having the book in hand it looks better then on screen. I also can't believe my FF 95 is a 9.4 and that book is a 9.6.

 

 

Actual vs my grades guesses:

 

Fantastic Four #95 OW-W 9.6 - 9.4

Fantastic Four #114 OW-W 9.0 - 9.2 (can't believe I bumped this one to a 9.2)

Giant Size Defenders #5 W 9.6 -9.4

Tales of Suspense #78 OW-W 9.0 - 8.0

 

I am definitely lucky to be moving on in this round.

 

[etanick]

Fantastic Four #95 OW-W 9.6

Fantastic Four #114 OW-W 9.0

Giant Size Defenders #5 W 9.6

Tales of Suspense #78 OW-W 9.0

 

here are my guesses

 

Etanick

SE region

round of 16

 

Fantastic Four #95 OW-W - 9.6 waffling from 9.2 to 9.4 and then up to 9.6.

Fantastic Four #114 OW-W - 9.0 highly confident

Giant Size Defenders #5 W - 9.6 highly confident

Tales of Suspense #78 OW-W - 8.5 waffling from 9.0 to 8.0 and then back up to 8.5....the damn production flaws on the spine was tough to ignore but the potential of the thumb print on the top edge was a bigger question mark.

 

glad to make it to the final 8...better luck with my contest Ark

[TheGeneral]

that last 9.0 was ugly

 

Tell me about it. I crashed and burned on that comic.

I spent more time this round staring at the slabs trying to figure out if it was a

scratch on the case or on the comic. Good luck to the Elite 8!

 

Good game Flee, I was way off on the TOS too (7.5).

[Flee-Marquette]

that last 9.0 was ugly

 

Tell me about it. I crashed and burned on that comic.

I spent more time this round staring at the slabs trying to figure out if it was a

scratch on the case or on the comic. Good luck to the Elite 8!

 

Good game Flee, I was way off on the TOS too (7.5).

Good game to you too General sir.

I had it at 7.0.

[divad]

...would sckao please report to the scorers table?.....

 

What happened?

 

(You changed the scoring by adding in the .2 differential and the spreadsheet array formula lookup probably didn't get totally updated...)

 

[burntboy]

that last 9.0 was ugly

 

This is really the first book I took exception to. If the URC on the FF 114 actually was NOT a crease what dropped it to the same grade as the TOS 78 that had 3 separate 1 inch color abrasions on the spine and a fuggly URC??

 

If that had been one of my SA DC's from 7 years ago it would have ben lucky to pull a 7.0...that book really scared me and deservedly so...

 

My congrats to all who advanced and to my opponent (Flat Rock) who blessedly decided to get into yet another defensive struggle with me...

 

How can a poor small school from the Patriot League, shuffled out to the NW, ever hope to compete with the Mighty Divad for a Final Four spot...