PGM ASM #16 just back from CGC

[cozman-migration]

You can see defects except for there is interior writing. I can't remember what it is but i think its a name written in ink.

 

 

 

[Spiderphill]

8.0, i wouldnt be surprised if cgc gave better though.

[ChrisInBaltimore]

8.5

[Hado]

8.5

[Buzzetta]

I will see your 8.5 and raise you a half grade to 9.0.

[rebelpk]

I will say 9.2. Probably overshooting but hey. It is a nice looking book.

[the420kid]

betting they graded tight as hell 7.5-8.0

[rodan57]

Difficult to tell.

 

I wouldn't want to see that abraided top left corner on an 8.5 but maybe the rest of the book is perfect.

 

(We can't tell if there are any spine issues given the scan size and white cover.)

[Conan_Aficionado]

8.0/8.5

[toyman-migration]

8.0

[ARK]

8.5 You need to get the scans bigger.

[cozman-migration]

I bought the Graders Notes:

Right Bottom Front Cover Lite Crease

Left Bottom Back Cover Crease

Spine Stress Lines

Top Front Cover Lite Stain

Interior Writing

 

 

[TSwift25]

It's hard to grade through the plastic at that size. Looks like significant wear in the top-left corner of the front cover, a few spine ticks and some wear to the bottom right of the front cover.

 

I'd say it's in the 8.0 range, but there may be more there that we can't see. Eye appeal is phenomenal though.

[cozman-migration]

This is as big as I can seem to make them.

 

 

 

 

[etanick]

it is hard to grade with what I can/can't see but based on the notes you got, I will throw in a wag of 8.5

 

[Aces]

9.0

[cozman-migration]

[zosocane]

Grader notes, please.

[Spiderphill]

Guess CGC destroyed that book for the "light" stain I cant even see. I think their stance on stains is harsher than ever lately.

[Peter Loves Gwen]

Guess CGC destroyed that book for the "light" stain I cant even see. I think their stance on stains is harsher than ever lately.

I figured that CGC would call it grade it close to that when I read the notes saying stain.

 

It looks very nice though. I have a #16 that looks very much like it, and CGC has found a few stains on books I have sent in.