PGM Amazing Spider-Man Annual 1

[WEBHEAD]

Thanks in advance for grading the all time Annual every made

 

 

 

 

[divad]

Solid 6.0 (even with the spine tear) Another classic! (thumbs u

[ROBTOTHEC]

That book is not above a 4.5! Without question. IMHO...

[divad]

That book is not above a 4.5! Without question. IMHO...

 

Technically, perhaps . . . but I respectfully disagree.

[frozentundraguy]

I would venture 5.0. Now if the back was the front.

[BarryAllen]

For what it is worth: solid 5.0, spine tear keeps it from higher.

 

Overall a great book with one of the all-time best villain teams!

[Vision75]

5.0 is my thinking too.

[trmoore54]

Not to mention ever made!

 

I'll split the difference and go 5.5...really nice cover whites!

[AnhDepTrai]

4.5

 

This copy look worse than the Swamp Thing #1 posted by the other boardie, with that big spine split (over 1 inch?) is that possible for it to get over 5.0 if submitted?

[ROBTOTHEC]

There is also a large 6 crease running through the top. And the bottom right corner looks worn. That with that pretty large upper left tear I am sticking with 4.5.

[makeminemego]

With the substantial creasing and the spine tear, I don't see the book coming back higher than 4.5, and it may come back as a 4.0.

 

Gorgeous book with great color, regardless of what it comes back as.

[divad]

With the substantial creasing and the spine tear, I don't see the book coming back higher than 4.5, and it may come back as a 4.0.

 

Gorgeous book with great color, regardless of what it comes back as.

 

I really don't think it's going anywhere . . .

[WEBHEAD]

never know time will tell

[makeminemego]

Sorry for my terminology. I wouldn't send it in either.

 

Presents well, and reads better.

 

Beautiful book. Enjoy!!

[Ghost Rider]

4.5 Nice book to own. I love my 6.5 WP Copy .I'm Tempted to set it free and be carefully read.

[Primetime]

4.5 if that spine split/tear into the FC was not there...that said, 3.5..